Shaduer’s NFL Projection makes no sense

[Gil Scott-Heroin]

A telltale sign of lazy analysis is using a single stat to focus in on a QB.

/thread.

 

[Supa]

I have to be honest. I prefer Cam Ward and Jalen Milroe.over Shadeur Sanders. He is a smart QB who layers his throws in short and intermediate distance. His arm to me is average and he has to realize the things he kind of got away with college won't work. Plus he's not fast enough to be truly a dual threat, imo so his accuracy has to be A-1 which I do think he is capable.

With that said this class is general is not as good as last year or next year's.

 

[Mull]

Playmaker and a good distributor of the ball. A LOT of pass catchers are catching passes from Shedeur. Not just Travis. Is he a perfect prospect no, but I do believe he will be just fine in the pros

 

[Braman]

A telltale sign of lazy analysis is using a single stat to focus in on a QB. You clearly have an agenda masquerading as "analysis" if you're trying to poke holes in every post who thinks Shedeur will be good.

Stop typing so many words and posts. Just say you hate him and we'll all salute you for being honest.

‘Use less words, u hatin’. So a more basic level discussion is your speed, say less.

In b4 ‘hate’ and ‘eye test’

 

[ReturnOfJudah]

I’ve heard Joe Burrow as a comparison.. and I actually think his ceiling is somewhere around there. Which is a massive W

He’s gotten better every year he’s been a QB, so the progress is in a positive direction

He has things to work on, but the tools are there.

His arm strength isn’t the best, and his deep ball accuracy is hit or miss. His awareness around the pocket is both elite, and a detriment in that he can take sacks he shouldn’t

He’s the #1 QB in this draft and I don’t think that’s a tough call at all

This you? cuz yall both getting beat down for saying this

 

[jaydawg08]

This you? cuz yall both getting beat down for saying this

You go to nearly every NFL draft mock site and a lot of them have Burrow as a potential comparison for Sanders

Not to say he’ll be that great, but the ceiling is around there

 

[CHICAGO]

This you? cuz yall both getting beat down for saying this

YET THAT POST FROM A NOBODY
HAS 7.3K LIKES....



​

 

[Braman]

Jalen Milroe?

Yeah @feelosofer you buggin with Milroe fam. Cmon now.

Now see, this is what I’m talking about. From 2 months ago:



Now we not about to get into a ‘PFF is just Cacs’ tangent, and whether you prefer Shaduer over Milroe isn’t even the point, the point is why is it crazy to you anyway?! You have NOTHING to go by other than public narratives. You ain’t cuttin up film ngga you don’t have all 22, you never played QB, you have no clue which pro throws teams value, you not qualified to scout footwork, etc. But bc you groupthink says so, you think you know Shaduer over Milroe

And bc I know how nggas like to discard 1 off sources….

Ryan Wilson's Latest Mock Draft: Jalen Milroe 1st QB Off Board, No. 5 To Browns - NewsBreak

Ryan Wilson joins Jaclyn DeAugustino to discuss Jalen Milroe being the first QB off the board going to the Browns at No. 5, according to Ryan Wilson's.

www.newsbreak.com

Mel Kiper: I Would Bet Alabama's Jalen Milroe Will Be 1st QB Picked in 2025 NFL Draft

Legendary draft expert Mel Kiper Jr. believes Alabama quarterback Jalen Milroe could climb to the top of the positional hierarchy once the 2025 NFL draft…

syndication.bleacherreport.com

 

[Rekkapryde]

Now see, this is what I’m talking about. From 2 months ago:



Now we not about to get into a ‘PFF is just Cacs’ tangent, and whether you prefer Shaduer over Milroe isn’t even the point, the point is why is it crazy to you anyway?! You have NOTHING to go by other than public narratives. You ain’t cuttin up film ngga you don’t have all 22, you never played QB, you have no clue which pro throws teams value, you not qualified to scout footwork, etc. But bc you groupthink says so, you think you know Shaduer over Milroe

And bc I know how nggas like to discard 1 off sources….

Ryan Wilson's Latest Mock Draft: Jalen Milroe 1st QB Off Board, No. 5 To Browns - NewsBreak

Ryan Wilson joins Jaclyn DeAugustino to discuss Jalen Milroe being the first QB off the board going to the Browns at No. 5, according to Ryan Wilson's.

www.newsbreak.com

Mel Kiper: I Would Bet Alabama's Jalen Milroe Will Be 1st QB Picked in 2025 NFL Draft

Legendary draft expert Mel Kiper Jr. believes Alabama quarterback Jalen Milroe could climb to the top of the positional hierarchy once the 2025 NFL draft…

syndication.bleacherreport.com

Aka it's all a crapshoot

But I'm not taking Milroe over Shadeur. You know that's nuts.

 

[Waka FICO Flamez]

Christian Ponder with two strand twists

 

[Adebisi_Said]

After reading through this thread, it's safe to assume the Giants will trade down and draft Travis Hunter and Leanna.

 

[King Poetic]

He will be defeated if he goes to the raiders and hype man spliff star is still the coach

 

[Braman]

Aka it's all a crapshoot

But I'm not taking Milroe over Shadeur. You know that's nuts.

No, I don’t.

Put it this way: Sam Howell, Aidan O’Connell are probably better pure passers than Anthony Richardson. He has looked terrible at time this year. Yet ask 32 GMs they are all taking him over them. As would I. Bc of upside. I doubt he runs, but if he does and it’s 4.4 range forget about it.

PLUS I think he’s seen as a Hurts/Cam type leader of men. Shaduer? I have my concerns.

Plus all the pull from his brand and his pops. It’s gonna be like dating a 7 who thinks she’s a dime. No thanks

 

[feelosofer]

Aka it's all a crapshoot

But I'm not taking Milroe over Shadeur. You know that's nuts.

But it's not nuts. We don't know what any of these QBs are going to be and Milroe is the most physically talented of the bunch and you can argue he has the biggest upside. You're making it seem like the gap between the two is astronomical and it isn't. He could very well develop into a Jalen Hurst-esque QB.

 

[Braman]

But it's not nuts. We don't know what any of these QBs are going to be and Milroe is the most physically talented of the bunch and you can argue he has the biggest upside. You're making it seem like the gap between the two is astronomical and it isn't. He could very well develop into a Jalen Hurst-esque QB.

Exactly. And the more reasonable the comp, the more likely. Milroe comped to Hurts or a more experienced Anthony Richardson is reasonable. Bc Hurts has come down a notch so he’s not some unicorn

Meanwhile Shaduer, or any QB, comped to Burrow is not reasonable. You don’t chase unicorns. Its a red flag if no one can name another successful, reasonable comp for Shaduer that’s not the 2nd best QB of the generation