What Quarterbacks today would you take over A Prime Mcnabb?
- Thread starter Street Knowledge
- Start date
sm0ke
Lin Kuei
Eli might be a bit much, you're right... he's more clutch than McNabb. But McNabb is my favorite quarterback since I started following the NFL heavy. Watching McNabb elude sacks in the pocket then throw a bullet to some scrub ass receiver was alwaysI was with you up till you said Eli. That boy's clutch gene is
to me.
Rapmastermind
Superstar
How many playoff wins does Romo and Rivers have? They aren't better than Mcnabb.
Of course not, I can't believe dudes in here have tried to include cats like Jay Cutler and Matt Ryan. No one in the league not named Peyton Manning, Tom Brady, Aaron Rodgers, Eli Manning, or Drew Brees is better than prime McNabb. And yes, that includes Ben Roethlisberger
sm0ke
Lin Kuei
What about Rothlisberger?
Ben is way better then McNabb..
No the fukk he's not.
You could argue that he's better, but for you to think the comparison is laughably in Ben's favor is stupid. I will never understand how morons and even some (not many, but some) educated football fans show such disrespect to a GREAT quarterback like McNabb.
Damn son you are the classic irrational fan.
You don't even believe that McNabb is better then Ben..
Damn son you are the classic irrational fan.
You don't even believe that McNabb is better then Ben..
He already said McNabb is his favorite QB ever....
After I read that I just ignored everything he said from that point on. You should do the same.
sm0ke
Lin Kuei
Damn son you are the classic irrational fan.
You don't even believe that McNabb is better then Ben..
Yes, he is. I'm not unrealistic about where I rank him, however. @klientel, you said half the current QBs are on or better than McNabb's level. That's obviously nothing more than irrational hate, so one should discredit your opinion long before they discredit mine.
Ben Roethlisberger can win superbowls, but he's still not the quarterback McNabb is.
Last edited by a moderator:
I agree to some extent, McNabb was never elite just as Ben isn't elite. I can see how someone could argue Ben being better than McNabb (though I disagree), but to scoff at the idea of McNabb being better than Ben is ridiculous.
Last edited by a moderator:
Formerly known as...
Collector
I never liked Mcnabb as much as others! Would never at any point choose to have him as my QB, but then I've been blessed with the GAWD Brady.
I'd take Matt Ryan, Eli, Ben, Rodgers, Brady, peyton over Mcflabb all day any day
I'd take Matt Ryan, Eli, Ben, Rodgers, Brady, peyton over Mcflabb all day any day
holidayinn21
:SmugMoneyMike:
. Please demonstrate where I have been inconsistent.
on one end it's he didn't have elite receivers, they you'll turn around and give david fukking givens credit for making plays. didn't freddie catch that 4th and 26? didn't he call plays while mcnabb was choking? pinkston didn't have 82 yards in the SB? didn't greg lewis catch a TD in the same game? didn't they make the SB w/o an injured T.O?
or does mcnabb get sole credit for that?
as I said, you give credit only when its convenient.
Born2BKing
Veteran
FreedS[ohh]lave
Banned
I cant put him over Big Ben...like Big Ben they both were better out of the pocket and could overpower defenders to avoid sacks the difference is Big Ben is a more accurate qb then Donovan
