What Quarterbacks today would you take over A Prime Mcnabb?

[True Weltch Media]

When all is said and done fukking Alex Smith could eclipse McNabb's career. Would you take Alex Smith over McNabb?

Cutler is > Alex Smith... no comparison at all there

and no.. Alex Smith's career is nowhere in the same ballpark as McNabb's.

Alex Smith is just along for the ride, while McNabb was a franchise QB for years.

 

[True Weltch Media]

all I know is if McNabb makes the Hall

than Kurt Warner should too.

 

[N.Y. State of Mind]

I'll never understand it man. Even on I was defending this dude. Folk forget when McNabb was right in the conversation (slightly behind) Manning and Brady. Matt Ryan though? Matt Schaub?

Yup. Dudes either forgot how nice he was, or just don't like him for whatever reason. He was one of the best qb's of the last decade plus.

 

[FTBS]

Exactly, people are only looking at one side of the ball.

Well this is football where players generally only play on one side of the ball. Why exactly would we be looking at the side of the ball that McNabb aka thread topic didnt' play on?

 

[True Weltch Media]

Yup. Dudes either forgot how nice he was, or just don't like him for whatever reason. He was one of the best qb's of the last decade plus.

Being in the Philly region the Eagles are ALWAYS on TV

I agree dude was entertaining to watch. could of been a legend

but everytime when Philly Fans needed him to step up in the clutch he

I still feel like if him and T.O. aint' split they could have won a superbowl especially with that elite defense he had.

 

[JLova]

When all is said and done fukking Alex Smith could eclipse McNabb's career. Would you take Alex Smith over McNabb?

How so?

Cutler and Alex Smith being talked about in the same breath as McNabb is an absolute joke.

 

[True Weltch Media]

Well this is football where players generally only play on one side of the ball. Why exactly would we be looking at the side of the ball that McNabb aka thread topic didnt' play on?

There saying that he had the luxury of having an elite defense year in and year out and still didn't get it done. hence the 5 NFC championship games and 0 rings

Tho i disagree with these kind of arguments, I understand what they trynna say.

 

[klientel]

all I know is if McNabb makes the Hall

than Kurt Warner should too.

Kurt Warner is getting in no doubt.

McNabb.....

 

[FTBS]

There saying that he had the luxury of having an elite defense year in and year out and still didn't get it done. hence the 5 NFC championship games and 0 rings

Tho i disagree with these kind of arguments, I understand what they trynna say.

If the defense was so elite why didn't THEY get it done then? Dilfer and Johnson got carried to rings by their respective defenses. The Colts D carried them the year they won with Peyton playing pretty par. Roethlisberger played like utter shyt in his first SB and still got a ring. Brady's D scored one TD and set up the second in his. Don't feed me this elite shyt when we saw truly elite defenses literally carry lesser qbs or qb performances to rings. I got nothing but respect for the late great JJ but how is a defense elite when it is known for being weak against the run?

 

[True Weltch Media]

How so?

Cutler and Alex Smith being talked about in the same breath as McNabb is an absolute joke.

They took my words out of context

Alex Smith is bottomline

what I said was I like Cutler's potential to end up having a better career than McNabb.

but as of right now Prime McNabb>Jay Cutler.

I hope this yall McNabb stans damn.

 

[Stone]

Well this is football where players generally only play on one side of the ball. Why exactly would we be looking at the side of the ball that McNabb aka thread topic didnt' play on?

Maybe because that side of the ball has alot to do with the success that he had. You seriously gonna ignore the fact that the Eagles had one of the best D-Coordinators ever? Eagles D was top 5 in scoring every year from 2000-2004. The same year that they got to those championship games.

Football is a team game, it's just that some of you want to only acknowledge this when it's convenient for you.

You can't pick and choose when you want to give credit.

 

[FTBS]

Maybe because that side of the ball has alot to do with the success that he had. You seriously gonna ignore the fact that the Eagles had one of the best D-Coordinators ever? Eagles D was top 5 in scoring every year from 2000-2004.

Football is a team game, it's just that some of you want to only acknowledge this when it's convenient for you.

You can't pick and choose when you want to give credit.

That's very true but it doesn't stop way too many people from doing it. If the D was so great why didn't it carry the squad to a SB title like other defenses during that time did? Don't talk to me about this great D doing so much and then wanna turn it around an throw it on Donovan when it comes to the Ls. You will never hear me talking about wins when referencing and individual unless I'm throwing somebody elses stupid reasoning back at them.

 

[True Weltch Media]

If the defense was so elite why didn't THEY get it done then? Dilfer and Johnson got carried to rings by their respective defenses. The Colts D carried them the year they won with Peyton playing pretty par. Roethlisberger played like utter shyt in his first SB and still got a ring. Brady's D scored one TD and set up the second in his. Don't feed me this elite shyt when we saw truly elite defenses literally carry lesser qbs or qb performances to rings. I got nothing but respect for the late great JJ but how is a defense elite when it is known for being weak against the run?

you don't think them Eagles defenses were Elite

so your blaming the Eagles defense then for McNabb never getting a ring

5 NFC Championships he should of at least got one ring.

The Eagles weren’t very good against the run up the middle so what Jim Johnson did was utilize Trotter’s straight line aggressiveness to his favor with a series of run blitzes. The Eagles would literally run blitz with Trotter for much of the game and that helped to keep him from having to play in space too often and it helped to slow down the opposition’s running game. Oh yeah, and he made a Pro-Bowler out of Trotter once again in 2005 and 2006.

Jim Johnson wasn’t afraid to take chances and he understood that he had to take the fight to the other team rather than reacting to what they did. He was like a General in the military who did a masterful job of assessing his troops strengths and weaknesses and those of the team he was getting ready to do battle against. If circumstances changed on the battlefield, he changed with them.

 

[FTBS]

you don't think them Eagles defenses were Elite

so your blaming the Eagles defense then for McNabb never getting a ring

5 NFC Championships he should of at least got one ring.

The Eagles weren’t very good against the run up the middle so what Jim Johnson did was utilize Trotter’s straight line aggressiveness to his favor with a series of run blitzes. The Eagles would literally run blitz with Trotter for much of the game and that helped to keep him from having to play in space too often and it helped to slow down the opposition’s running game. Oh yeah, and he made a Pro-Bowler out of Trotter once again in 2005 and 2006.

Jim Johnson wasn’t afraid to take chances and he understood that he had to take the fight to the other team rather than reacting to what they did. He was like a General in the military who did a masterful job of assessing his troops strengths and weaknesses and those of the team he was getting ready to do battle against. If circumstances changed on the battlefield, he changed with them.

I'm saying nikkas need to be consistent. If you wanna talk about the D talk about the D just don't stop and try to flip it over to Donovan when we are talking about the Ls. The truly elite Ds of the day carried lesser QBs to titles.

 

[True Weltch Media]

Having an Elite Defense doesn't = a Superbowl

I've seen Elite Defenses my whole life that didn't win rings


90's Steelers- Neil Odonnel, Kordell Stewart

Early 00's Eagles-McNabb

Late 00's Ravens-Flacco

2011 49ers- Alex Smith

etc etc. all never won rings with elite defenses.

bottomline is you need a QB wit heart to make big clutch plays to win a superbowl. and the truth is McNabb came up short, everytime.

I hate when people bring up Trent Dilfer, and Brad Johnson they are exceptions to the rule.