WSJ: Patrick Mahomes has kept an entire generation of Quarterbacks from winning a Superbowl.

Regular_P

Just end the season.
Joined
May 1, 2012
Messages
80,375
Reputation
10,133
Daps
215,415
I haven't seen anyone mention that this exact same garbage could have been written about Brady heading into the 2005 playoffs. Brad Johnson was the only QB to win a Super Bowl in that time period and he was drafted in 1992. :skip:
 

Copy Ninja

Superstar
Joined
Dec 19, 2014
Messages
9,180
Reputation
690
Daps
32,802
i was just selecting the dates based on when they were winning super bowls, i agree that the teams up through 2007 were more like the 01-04 teams. they still had a lot of the core defensive players like bruschi, vrabel, richard seymour, rodney harrison, wilfork, and some of the guys on the o line. then by 2011 theyve got gronk and some of the other guys who would be there for their second dynasty

I remember this! And then Von and them destroyed Brady in the AFC Championship. I think that game, is the most I ever saw Brady get hit. He got peppered but he also proved his toughness in that game...

I think if you're gonna split the Patriot dynasty you gotta go from 2001 thru 2007. The line of demarcation was Brady getting hurt W1 2008, and the Patriots going on a 4-year drought to get back to the Super Bowl...

I think you can start the second leg of their dynasty in 2011 when they went back to the Super Bowl, 2011 thru 2018. Most people don't remember the 4-year drought, so it's easy to combine both stretches as one dynasty. I get it...

Its kinda like how the Spurs are often credited as a 15-year dynasty, even though they themselves went 7 years between winning championships once...

Their actual dynasty was 1998-2008, '08 being last appearance in WCF for 4 years, 1998-99 season being their first championship. The Comeback Spurs of 2012-14 only won one title, so they weren't a dynasty, but that era gets included in the "Spurs dynasty"....

Great QBs do have an outsized impact, though. Agree with all else you said...

You can basically split the Pats run by their defensive core. The first run we had guys like McGinest, Seymour, Harrison, Law, Vrabel, Colvin, Bruschi. Then those guys left and we didn't have a lot of guys on D outside of Wilfork and Mayo.

Our second run started when we got players like Hightower, McCourty, Ninkovich, Chung, Jones, Collins, Flowers, Gilmore. The offense with Brady was always great, but like the old adage 'defense wins championships'.

As great as Mahomes is, it's going to be the defense that's going to help him catch Brady.
 
Top