49ers could be in trouble
The
San Francisco 49ers have been here before and lived to tell about it. Just last season, they turned a 1-2 start into a 12-4 record that would have won the NFC West in any other season since divisional realignment, and an eventual trip to the NFC Championship Game. On the surface, there's no reason for panic.
The 49ers are five-point favorites against the
Philadelphia Eagles this week, and will likely be favored against the
Kansas City Chiefs and
St. Louis Rams thereafter. Winning those games to reach 4-2 would shatter the doom-and-gloom scenarios that can take hold prematurely after a couple of defeats.
Unfortunately for the 49ers, their problems run deeper this season. The warning signs are more acute, threatening a championship window the team has worked hard to keep open against lengthening odds. The stakes are also higher as coach Jim Harbaugh works through the fourth year of his five-year contract, and with the team not completely locked into keeping
Colin Kaepernick as its starting quarterback beyond the 2015 season (more on both of those later). This is a potentially combustible situation, one that deserves a closer look as the 49ers approach their Week 4 home game against unbeaten Philadelphia.
There is no single fundamental flaw with the 49ers. The question is whether they can overcome the cumulative weight of many factors aligned against them at once. It's also worth considering the potential bigger-picture fallout if the season falls apart.
ESPN analyst Trent Dilfer finished his career with the 49ers and maintains ties to the organization. I found it telling the other day when he summed up the team's problems this way in a conversation with Colin Cowherd: "I think the team is worse -- significantly worse [than past seasons]. Not from a talent standpoint; they're still a very, very talented team. They lack discipline. They've lost it. They've lost what makes really good teams good. That's playing for one another, that's playing a high level of discipline in situations. [They] don't have the same energy."
Warning signs
•
Questionable discipline: Seattle won the Super Bowl last season after leading the NFL in most penalties, so we shouldn't make too much of the 49ers' league-high total (41) through three games. Excessive penalties can still be a sign of questionable discipline. Off the field, the 49ers suffered from a
league-high 10 player arrests over a 32-month period entering this season. The nine-game suspension for top pass-rusher
Aldon Smith was costly. Penalties and arrests aren't related, of course, but both contribute to perceptions that the 49ers could use a course correction.
•
Too many key injuries: San Francisco's strength on the offensive line has underwritten its offensive success in recent seasons. A hamstring injury has prevented right tackle
Anthony Davis from playing. Tight ends
Vernon Davis and
Vance McDonald missed the team's most recent game, also affecting the line. Third-round pick
Marcus Martin, drafted to help with depth on the line, was lost to injury. On defense, the 49ers used a smaller rotation in past seasons because their inside linebackers were dominant three-down players.
NaVorro Bowman's injury has changed the dynamic. Losing
Glenn Dorsey also hurt.
•
Players underperforming: Guards
Mike Iupati and
Alex Boone have struggled to this point in the season, which wouldn't mean as much if the team weren't already playing without Davis at right tackle. On defense, outside linebacker
Ahmad Brooks has made little impact, which wouldn't matter as much if Smith were playing. "Brooks was hot and cold in the past, but he played his butt off, and now he is not playing as well," a personnel director said.
•
Roster attrition: Good teams must make difficult choices about the players they can afford to sign and re-sign. The 49ers have been making those tough choices for a few seasons now. They haven't lost any must-keep players, but they've invested considerable draft capital replacing players such as
Dashon Goldson,
Delanie Walker and
Donte Whitner.
•
Aging of the team: The 49ers went into Week 3 with the third-oldest starters in the league by average age. That isn't necessarily bad. New Orleans, Carolina, Arizona and Denver are also in the top 10. Jacksonville has the third-youngest starters and isn't very competitive. Still, age can be an indicator as to where a team stands in its life cycle. Is the window closer to closing than opening in San Francisco? Note that Seattle has the NFL's second-youngest group of starters.
•
Low impact from draft picks: The 49ers have gotten 15 starts this season from the 40 players they drafted beginning in 2011, Harbaugh's first season. That is the lowest figure in the league and seven below the average. A strong roster has made it tougher for some rookies to factor, but that is only part of the story. Bowman's injury and Smith's suspension have hurt the total. The 2012 draft featured high-profile misses in A.J. Jenkins and LaMichael James.
•
Taxing three-year grind: The 49ers won 76 percent of their regular-season games during Harbaugh's first three seasons, but each one of those seasons ended in crushing fashion. We rightfully give the early 1990s
Buffalo Bills credit for continually bouncing back from Super Bowl losses. That team had a philosophical and intellectual leader in head coach in Marv Levy. The 49ers are wound tighter, which leads into the next item.
•
Volatile head coach: Harbaugh's critics think his abrasive, hard-charging style carries a shelf life, and that once things go bad, they'll go
really bad. We've touched on this one before, and there's no point in belaboring it. Only time will tell.
•
Coach-GM dynamic: Team CEO Jed York has called the tension between Harbaugh and general manager Trent Baalke a creative one, casting it as a situation where two highly competitive professionals sometimes butt heads in pursuit of the greater good. York also has denied that the team nearly traded Harbaugh to Cleveland last offseason. Whatever the case, there are certainly unanswered questions about the long-term sustainability of this alliance.
Potential fallout
The 49ers have so far hedged their bets on Harbaugh and Kaepernick, raising the stakes for how the season unfolds from here. Contract talks with Harbaugh haven't gone anywhere in the past, but there hasn't been a deadline yet, either. He says he wants to stay and has no other aspirations. Talks will become a leading subject again in the offseason whether or not the team finishes strong. If the season falls apart or again ends in heartbreak, we'll find out just how sustainable the relationship between Harbaugh and the 49ers remains.
Change at the top could affect every level of the organization, including the outlook at quarterback. Kaepernick's contract makes him a strong favorite to remain the starter for years to come, but if a new coaching staff wanted to go in another direction, the deal allows the team that flexibility.
If Kaepernick stays, as expected, his contract is scheduled to count between $15 million and $19 million per season, making it tougher for the 49ers to maintain their roster to keep open their championship window. Meanwhile, the contracts for
Frank Gore,
Michael Crabtree,
Chris Culliver and Iupati are expiring.
Justin Smith turns 35 this month and it's tough to know what the future holds for
Aldon Smith.
These far-off thoughts won't matter so much if the 49ers can replicate their 2013 reversal. If they can, Harbaugh can make an even stronger case he deserves top dollar. But with so many factors working against him, including strong competition from within the division, it's not going to be easy.
Notes
•
Rookie QB evaluations: We're conditioned to think young quarterbacks need time to realize their potential, and it makes sense. However, there is some evidence suggesting QBs never deviate too much from what they show during their first season starting, health permitting.
Bill Polian and I covered that ground
for a column back in April, and his conclusion has implications for
Teddy Bridgewater and
Blake Bortles, the two 2014 first-round picks recently installed as starters.
"The QBs who do well ultimately, do well as rookies or in their first season of starting -- they show you," Polian said. "If they are not above a certain threshold after their first 16 games, the odds are pretty good that they will not be a franchise quarterback. The odds are even stronger that they will wash out completely."
•
Getting the ball out quickly: Sometimes you'll hear a coach explain his team's low sack total by saying the opponents are making a special effort to get the ball out quickly. Jeff Fisher alluded to this after his St. Louis Rams headed into their bye week with one sack in three games. The Rams averaged 3.3 sacks per game last season, third most in the NFL.
Was Fisher on point? Yes. The Rams' opponents have passed the ball 2.36 seconds after the snap on average, the sixth-lowest figure in the league. That is down from 2.49 seconds last season and 2.54 in 2012, Fisher's first season as head coach.
Some quarterbacks get the ball out quickly regardless of the opponent. Some hold the ball much longer in general. Baltimore's first three opponents (Cincinnati, Pittsburgh and Cleveland) have gotten rid of the ball after just 2.16 seconds on average, fastest in the league. Opponents for Miami (2.21), Kansas City (2.24), Indianapolis (2.3) and Tennessee (2.35) round out the top five.
•
The leading edge: Last season, the
Washington Redskins ran a league-low 115 offensive plays while holding a lead on the scoreboard. They have already run 91 plays while leading through three games, the eighth-highest number in the league. Tampa Bay (five plays) and Green Bay (15) are at the other end of the spectrum this season. How much can the Packers lean on
Eddie Lacy if they're almost never leading?
•
Wilson-Luck revisited: I asked a personnel director what he thought about
Denver Broncos cornerback
Chris Harris' recent contention that
Russell Wilson is
better than
Andrew Luck.
His answer: "The Broncos have faced both teams, and they struggled a bit more with the last guy [Wilson], and that hands-on experience tells him that of the two guys they faced, one played extremely well or above and beyond better. I would say he has a legitimate claim. It could be [credible] since he has faced them both and dissected them both and had on-the-field experience."