Stop playing with this man. Mahomes the GOAT

[broller]

I don’t care what Bruschi says. We watched the games what are you talking about? Some of us are old enough to have been there in real time. You sound 24. What did KC rely on this year b? Last year? Did Bruschi mention that time him and the defense gave up 29 points in one half in a SB? Did he mention that Brady was getting MVP votes before he ever got Moss? Did he forget Brady led the NFL in passing yards and attempts before Moss ever got there because the running game was ineffective? Like you’re talking to people who were there and watched it and can cite to the stats.

Mahomes came into the league with the most dynamic offensive weapons in the NFL. His numbers haven’t looked anything like they without them. His team this year and last was literally what Brady spent over a third of his career dealing with minus having a Kelce.

Just out of curiosity, what do you think Teddy was doing while we were watching the games the audacity

Facts. I mean it's reasonable to say Brady is still the best but some of his points were just so off base, especially obviously that one..

 

[Rekkapryde]

It's way too early to crown Mahomes as the GOAT. He needs at least 5 which is not impossible.

He ties Joe and he passes him IMO. Won't even be because that's how it should be. Progression.

Pat is firmly 3rd for me right now. Ties Joe and he's 2nd hands down IMO. Don't even think he needs to get to 7 to pass Tom either. But dude is the Total Package. Arm Talent, Mobility, Clutch, and strikes fear. That's the thing about Tom that was so crazy, you give him the ball in the clutch and you know what was gonna happen. fukkery included.

He'll need 5 for me to even have the debate about GOAT with Tom. But talent wise, can't think of anyone better.

 

[GreatestLaker]

It's way too early to crown Mahomes as the GOAT. He needs at least 5 which is not impossible.

Was Brady ever as good as current Mahomes?

In fact was Brady at any point in his career the undisputed best QB in the league?

 

[Jplaya2023]

Was Brady ever as good as current Mahomes?

In fact was Brady at any point in his career the undisputed best QB in the league?

2007

 

[feelosofer]

Was Brady ever as good as current Mahomes?

In fact was Brady at any point in his career the undisputed best QB in the league?

I would argue from 2007 through 2018 he was 1 if not 2. Now again if you're talking pure talent then no doubt Mahomes has it and I would say he is #3 if he never throws another snap but there is a lot of career left for him.

 

[FabTrey]

Was Brady ever as good as current Mahomes?

In fact was Brady at any point in his career the undisputed best QB in the league?

If you've watched football, Brady has been the consensus best QB almost every year last decade. in 00's he shared that honor with Manning.


Brady won NFL top 100 4 times. I feel this is a more accurate #1 then MVP or all pro. those are pretty stat award which is a result of offensive system and weapons.

2011


2017


2018


2022



2016 - #2
2015 - #3
2014 - #3
2013 - #4
2012 - #4


Brady has most #1, and most top 5 finishes.


Also Brady has been the consensus GOAT since 28-3. That's when many felt Brady surpassed Montana.

In fact, many claimed Brady as the GOAT of NFL ever since 28-3 happened.


When Brady went to Tampa and beat Mahomes to win the SB? Many claimed Brady is the GOAT of team sports



Brady to me has the greatest resume in the north american team sports. Honestly, nobody really come close IMO.

 

[JYoung24]

Contexts matters and he had a horrible start in the playoffs which skews some of those numbers that first Superbowl he went against the top 3 defenses and lead a big comeback in the NFC championship

 

[Supa]

Peyton Manning had a passer rating of 87.4 with 7,339 yards, 40 touchdowns and 25 interceptions in 27 games in the playoffs in his career.

Thats 271.8 yds, 1.4 tds, .9 ints a game

9 one and dones

3 tds and 4 interceptions in the Super Bowl

Lol the only 4th quarter td was a pick six

Someone in another thread before the Super Bowl was trying to tell me it was too early to put Mahomes over Peyton

 

[Chip Skylark]

Someone in another thread before the Super Bowl was trying to tell me it was too early to put Mahomes over Peyton

This 3rd ring and Pat playoff performances for sure put him over Peyton. I’m sure he’ll catch up with MVPs before it’s all said and done too

 

[GreatestLaker]

 

[Lucky_Lefty]

Brady to me has the greatest resume in the north american team sports. Honestly, nobody really come close IMO.

 

[Chip Skylark]

7 MVPs straight is nuts

His resume is bonkers

 

[kdslittlebro]

No…. Actually Mahomes got the Second Chance after second chance…. After second chance

Say breh, you ain’t been in our thread like before, you don’t fw us no more?

 

[kdslittlebro]

Peyton Manning had a passer rating of 87.4 with 7,339 yards, 40 touchdowns and 25 interceptions in 27 games in the playoffs in his career.

Thats 271.8 yds, 1.4 tds, .9 ints a game

9 one and dones

3 tds and 4 interceptions in the Super Bowl

Lol the only 4th quarter td was a pick six

FRAUD

 

[Chip Skylark]

Say breh, you ain’t been in our thread like before, you don’t fw us no more?

He sure has been quiet