The NBA’s core problem is that in order to maximize the global appeal of the game, they had to completely alter the product to create a showcase type of basketball that purists despise and players largely don’t give a fukk about.
Compare this to the NFL, NHL and MLB. These leagues are considered the peak of their sports in terms of playing in a traditional manner, that also happens to be entertaining. I had a friend who basically said “if you love hockey you love the NHL” because the rules and gameplay are very in line with how traditional hockey is played.
The NBA lets players get away with countless carries, travels, thrive off of free throws, has inconsistent officiating, and has ruled physicality out of the game. This makes for a stark viewing experience especially when compared to say FIBA which has more physical, grind it out matches that often time rewards teams just for being bigger and stronger.
The lack of tradition and prestige also trickles down into the player culture. NFL, Major league baseball and the NHL have very rich cultures and proud traditions so playing in the league is considered a huge honor. Players feel honored and pride being apart of certain clubs like the Yankees, Bruins, Steelers, Niners, Eagles… you really only see this in the NBA with the Celtics and maybe the Spurs and Lakers. The NBA is just way too player centric.
The other league players have more respect for their sports reputation, but additionally there’s always the danger of the “next guy up” that I think keeps a lot of these players loyal and willing to fall in line with whatever club they play for.
That’s not really a thing in the NBA as even complete busts like Johnny Davis, James Wiseman, and Jahlil Okafor are still hanging around NBA rosters. This creates a culture of comfort and complacency with the players. And that’s not even factoring in how these contracts make these guys too comfortable and non-waivable. Jeff Teague (who is the spokesperson of unserious and apathetic player culture, though I love his podcast) basically said that he stopped giving a fukk after he got his second contract, and he played for four more years after getting his contract
Lastly, showcase Basketball product just wasnt meant to be this 3 ball centric. as I said in another post, the three ball solves a lot of logistic issues that make roster building easier and creates parity, but don’t exactly make for a viable viewing product. The funny thing is, spamming the three ball is still the best way to play winning basketball as our ability to hit the three ball is what made the USA successful in the Olympics.