YOUR Top 10 Singles Of 1999

mobbinfms

Veteran
Supporter
Joined
Aug 10, 2012
Messages
37,354
Reputation
15,430
Daps
93,767
Reppin
TPC
I don't have a narrative. I'm bringing up 1997 because you're comparing her 1999 album to the one she dropped in 1997. Were you not comparing the first week sales and chart position from 1997 to the first week sales and chart position of 1999?
Yeah. You are clearly confused. Go back from the start and try to reread he exchange and get back to me.
 

mobbinfms

Veteran
Supporter
Joined
Aug 10, 2012
Messages
37,354
Reputation
15,430
Daps
93,767
Reppin
TPC
#7 is disappointing to whom?

The increase if sales as a whole has nothing to do with individual sales. I just proved that a lot of artist's were selling less than 25% of what they did in 1997. Missy was pretty much in the same position she was in back in 1997 in 1999.
Missy. Timbaland. Her label. Fans who wanted to see her chart higher.

Same position except her singles weren’t connecting, her album didn’t chart as high and it took 3.5 times longer to be certified platinum.
 

JustCKing

Superstar
Joined
Jun 17, 2012
Messages
25,435
Reputation
3,916
Daps
48,290
Reppin
NULL
An album can’t be prematurely certified. The RIAA has to do an audit and confirm the shipments minus returns. Hence the word “certification”.

Taking the Reasonable inferences from the evidence we have, my Scenario makes the most sense. If you don’t want to use Reasonable inferences, we have to go back to she hadn’t shipped gold until February of 2000. But that contradicts the chart positions in 1999 to me, but I’m having to make a reasonable inference about what those chart positions mean. And as you’ve said repeatedly, they mean nothing.

They can. This should've been mentioned before, but Supa Dupa Fly would've had to sell 145K per week after release to reach 1,000,000 copies in two months.

You don't necessarily have to sell 1M to get a platinum certification. The label has to apply for certification once they have data to prove that 1 million units have been shipped. The RIAA performs an audit and based on the audit, they certify the album or single. If that album meets requirements for platinum, it automatically gets a gold certification.

Now in Da Real World's case, Elektra could've been holding out for a platinum certification being that the gold certification would've been automatic. Also, "Hot Boyz" went platinum at the same time. So that's three plaques at the same time.

And Missy actually had platinum party for Da Real World in November 1999:

 
Last edited:

JustCKing

Superstar
Joined
Jun 17, 2012
Messages
25,435
Reputation
3,916
Daps
48,290
Reppin
NULL
I’m not sure what you’re taking about here.
I thought the dispute was whether the Box was different across the country? Based on what i posted, it appears that’s the case.




^^^^ The Box logo on this shows that it was indeed available.

No it wasn't. It makes no sense that a video like Juve's would not appear on all playlists. When you look at the explanation, the only difference across the country was in regard to local, obscure artists. In which case, the playlist was customized to showcase those artists. Juvenile was not local or obscure.
 
Last edited:

JustCKing

Superstar
Joined
Jun 17, 2012
Messages
25,435
Reputation
3,916
Daps
48,290
Reppin
NULL
Missy. Timbaland. Her label. Fans who wanted to see her chart higher.

Same position except her singles weren’t connecting, her album didn’t chart as high and it took 3.5 times longer to be certified platinum.

None of them have ever expressed disappointment in her debuting at #10. Again, you're grasping at straws and just throwing anything at the wall at this point. No proof. And you've conceded that she sold most of her copies in 1999. So I don't know what you're still harping on.

This wasn't label panic where they just started throwing records at the wall hoping something stuck. They already had these singles planned and in the pipeline prior to the album dropping.

And again, the chart position of the album is irrelevant. How much it sold is far more important.
 

mobbinfms

Veteran
Supporter
Joined
Aug 10, 2012
Messages
37,354
Reputation
15,430
Daps
93,767
Reppin
TPC
They can. This should've been mentioned before, but Supa Dupa Fly would've had to sell 145K per week after release to reach 1,000,000 copies in two months.

You don't necessarily have to sell 1M to get a platinum certification.
Of course you don’t have to actually sell one million to get the plat certification. It’s shipments minus returns. So what is the relevance of what Missy would have had to sell in 97?

And this is not evidence of premature certification.

I would agree with you that Missy’s first album was certified platinum prior to actually selling one million copies, that seems like a reasonable inference based on the evidence. But I also know you don’t accept inferences or assumptions and demand proof. So where are the soundscan numbers week by week for both albums?
 

mobbinfms

Veteran
Supporter
Joined
Aug 10, 2012
Messages
37,354
Reputation
15,430
Daps
93,767
Reppin
TPC
Now in Da Real World's case, Elektra could've been holding out for a platinum certification being that the gold certification would've been automatic.
That’s an assumption. Why are you permitted to assume but I’m not in this discussion?
 

mobbinfms

Veteran
Supporter
Joined
Aug 10, 2012
Messages
37,354
Reputation
15,430
Daps
93,767
Reppin
TPC


^^^^ The Box logo on this shows that it was indeed available.

No it wasn't. It makes no sense that a video like Juve's would not appear on all playlists. When you look at the explanation, the only difference across the country was in regard to local, obscure artists. In which case, the playlist was customized to showcase those artists. Juvenile was not local or obscure.

I’m not weighing in on the Juvenile aspect of the debate you and @Wacky D are having.
Clearly you’ve now agree that the Box was different across the country.

And the assumption that you are making isnt. even reasonable. Do you have actual proof that there was some mandatory nationwide playlist that the local Box affiliates had to play? Otherwise, since you are assuming, I will assume it would be more likely that Juvenile would have got more Box AirPlay in ATL than Philly.
 

mobbinfms

Veteran
Supporter
Joined
Aug 10, 2012
Messages
37,354
Reputation
15,430
Daps
93,767
Reppin
TPC
Because nothing supports your argument of them not certifying the album to avoid making Da Real World look like a flop.
Common sense does.
If you have an artist who goes platinum quickly with their first album, the follow up album only going gold in the same period of time would be perceived as a regression correct? The record label, which wants to make as much money out of Missy as possible, wouldn’t want that to be the perception if they could avoid it correct?
 
Top