Read his post again.
Dropped with no video. According to YouTube this video was released in 1998. FOMFBOMB released on 12/22/1998. Unless, this video dropped after that, I stand corrected. Also, "Slippin" dropped in 1998 as well before the album.
Read his post again.
No. To the contrary, you selectively applied the criteria to make your case and ignored the criteria that didn’t support your case.
What do you mean no proof has been given?
I posted the first week chart positions, how the singles performed, the time it took for the albums to be certified platinum. How is that not proof? And if that’s not proof, what would be proof?
No. To the contrary, you selectively applied the criteria to make your case and ignored the criteria that didn’t support your case.
Because you ignored the first week sales/chart position for X. Therefore, selective application.How so? you are admittedly telling me that I was correct about the singles, and the album sales. I didn't selectively apply anything. I mean, for all intents and purposes, I repeatedly pointed out how Missy had a bigger first week (a couple thousand more) than her previous record and you IGNORED this fact and continued to call it a flop.
So what are the criteria for a flop then? What is the evidence we should be considering if everything I pointed to is irrelevant?Because none of that justifies a flop. First week chart positions are based on a number of factors. What else was out at the time and who else dropped on that day affect chart positions and don't necessarily spell flop. And if we are taling into consideration the time it takes an album to go platinum, that also doesn't spell flop especially if you're not being consistent with applying this to other artists.
Sure. A number #3 one week can be #4 the next.First week chart positions are based on a number of factors. What else was out at the time and who else dropped on that day affect chart positions and don't necessarily spell flop.
Which criteria did I ignore with regard to which album? Please be specific.Breh, you're in here ignoring your own criteria.
Which is what? Beyond album sales at the end of album cycle? That’s all I recall you saying in this thread. What else is there?My criteria is criteria that I have used and applied to other albums.
Which criteria did I ignore with regard to which album? Please be specific.
Because you ignored the first week sales/chart position for X. Therefore, selective application.
I addressed your point about Missy before you even made it by pointing out that her sales should have been higher in 99. Turns out they were marginally higher but resulted in a #10 debut compared to #3 in 97. That’s significant.
Which is what? Beyond album sales at the end of album cycle? That’s all I recall you saying in this thread. What else is there?
Which criteria did I ignore?Missy's album.
Which criteria did I ignore?