Who's the better Quarterback? And whos career was better? Tom Brady or Peyton Manning

No1

Retired.
Supporter
Joined
Apr 30, 2012
Messages
30,606
Reputation
4,858
Daps
68,487
QFT.

The Pats D was the strength of that team during their SB victories. They shut down teams defensively. shyt, who knows what would have happened with that tuck rule shyt either which was a complete joke just to shyt on Al Davis.

Just say you don't know shyt about the Patriots and Tom Brady and you think he's overrated and keep it moving. You demonstrated it with that last essay. This is @FTBS and @Born2BKing too. You my dude, but really an Al Davis conspiracy :facepalm: The tuck rule was the actual rule cats are acting like that wasn't the rule :russ:

I'm so tired of people feigning impartiality when they know damn well that Cassel inherited a team that had just gone 18-0 and Peyton's team was looking like it would miss the playoffs WITH Peyton.

But sure let's compare the greatest offensive team of Brady's career to the worst Colts team since 99 and say that shows Brady was overrated. Like do you guys really expect anyone to take you serious when you act purposefully obtuse?

or MAYBE you guys just don't watch football games. This is Tom fukkin Brady who led the NFL in passing yards with Deion Branch and David fukking Givens and average WRs like that, go ahead and put Matt Cassel on THAT team.

How about we give Matt Cassel the 2004 Colts offense with Edge, Marvin and Reggie in their primes and then see what would happen. :what:

There's an argument for Peyton, but using that shyt automatically disqualifies your opinion, it shows ignorance of history and context. That's really just my two cents on the subject because I'm not evaluating them again until their done.

:obamaword:@that defense argument though, you're going to say shyt when Brady had throw a completion record in that shoot out vs. the Panthers. Get out.
 
Last edited by a moderator:

FTBS

Superstar
Joined
May 29, 2012
Messages
19,611
Reputation
3,270
Daps
52,969
Reppin
NULL
Just say you don't know shyt about the Patriots and Tom Brady and you think he's overrated and keep it moving. You demonstrated it with that last essay. This is @FTBS and @Born2BKing too.

I'm so tired of people feigning impartiality when they know damn well that Cassel inherited a team that had just gone 18-0 and Peyton's team was looking like it would miss the playoffs WITH Peyton.

But sure let's compare the greatest offensive team of Brady's career to the worst Colts team since 99 and say that shows Brady was overrated. Like do you guys really expect anyone to take you serious when you act purposefully obtuse?

or MAYBE you guys just don't watch football games. This is Tom fukkin Brady who led the NFL in passing yards with Deion Branch and David fukking Givens and average WRs like that, go ahead and put Matt Cassel on THAT team.

How about we give Matt Cassel the 2004 Colts offense with Edge, Marvin and Reggie in their primes and then see what would happen. :what:

There's an argument for Peyton, but using that shyt automatically disqualifies your opinion, it shows ignorance of history and context. That's really just my two cents on the subject because I'm not evaluating them again until their done.

:obamaword:@that defense argument though, you're going to say shyt when Brady had throw a completion record in that shoot out vs. the Panthers. Get out.

If you wanna address me address what I said...not some strawman shyt or shyt other nikkas said. I never said a word about Cassell. Never compared the 07 team to Peytons' 99 team. I'm really kinda confused why you even mentioned me. :manny:
 
Last edited by a moderator:

Rekkapryde

GT, LWO, 49ERS, BRAVES, HAWKS, N4O...yeah UMAD!
Supporter
Joined
May 1, 2012
Messages
150,470
Reputation
27,627
Daps
506,780
Reppin
TYRONE GA!
Just say you don't know shyt about the Patriots and Tom Brady and you think he's overrated and keep it moving. You demonstrated it with that last essay. This is @FTBS and @Born2BKing too. You my dude, but really an Al Davis conspiracy :facepalm: The tuck rule was the actual rule cats are acting like that wasn't the rule :russ:

I'm so tired of people feigning impartiality when they know damn well that Cassel inherited a team that had just gone 18-0 and Peyton's team was looking like it would miss the playoffs WITH Peyton.

But sure let's compare the greatest offensive team of Brady's career to the worst Colts team since 99 and say that shows Brady was overrated. Like do you guys really expect anyone to take you serious when you act purposefully obtuse?

or MAYBE you guys just don't watch football games. This is Tom fukkin Brady who led the NFL in passing yards with Deion Branch and David fukking Givens and average WRs like that, go ahead and put Matt Cassel on THAT team.

How about we give Matt Cassel the 2004 Colts offense with Edge, Marvin and Reggie in their primes and then see what would happen. :what:

There's an argument for Peyton, but using that shyt automatically disqualifies your opinion, it shows ignorance of history and context. That's really just my two cents on the subject because I'm not evaluating them again until their done.

:obamaword:@that defense argument though, you're going to say shyt when Brady had throw a completion record in that shoot out vs. the Panthers. Get out.

Forgot Brady is a Michigan man, so I cant take your opinion seriously :youngsabo:
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Joined
May 7, 2012
Messages
27,792
Reputation
4,712
Daps
103,465
The funniest shyt I read in here is that Brady magically got better once he got Moss and Welker. :dead:

No, dummies, his numbers got better, Brady was just as trill as ever. Brady finally getting weapons and then setting the league on fire proved our assertions correct: Tom Brady > Peyton Manning.
 

No1

Retired.
Supporter
Joined
Apr 30, 2012
Messages
30,606
Reputation
4,858
Daps
68,487
If you wanna address me address what I said...not some strawman shyt or shyt other nikkas said. I never said a word about Cassell. Never compared the 07 team to Peytons' 99 team. I'm really kinda confused why you even mentioned me. :manny:

The first sentence was dedicated you, it was all inclusive about cats making dishonest arguments and you dapped up some of their comments so why wouldn't I include you?
 
Joined
Nov 20, 2012
Messages
7
Reputation
0
Daps
10
Reppin
NULL
:whoa:
Everyone is getting gassed by all these great regular seasons numbers Manning always puts up. You all will be brought down to earth again when the playoffs arrive and Manning chokes the Broncos season away - as he normally does in the playoffs.

people stay talking about peyton choking in the playoffs but he has better numbers than brady does. and brady has choked plenty of times and got bailed out. peyton is a etter qb period and can play in any system
 

No1

Retired.
Supporter
Joined
Apr 30, 2012
Messages
30,606
Reputation
4,858
Daps
68,487
people stay talking about peyton choking in the playoffs but he has better numbers than brady does. and brady has choked plenty of times and got bailed out. peyton is a etter qb period and can play in any system

You created a new username just to dikk ride Peyton. :thiswork:
 

Born2BKing

Veteran
Joined
May 1, 2012
Messages
83,661
Reputation
14,939
Daps
332,815
Just say you don't know shyt about the Patriots and Tom Brady and you think he's overrated and keep it moving. You demonstrated it with that last essay. This is @FTBS and @Born2BKing too. You my dude, but really an Al Davis conspiracy :facepalm: The tuck rule was the actual rule cats are acting like that wasn't the rule :russ:

I'm so tired of people feigning impartiality when they know damn well that Cassel inherited a team that had just gone 18-0 and Peyton's team was looking like it would miss the playoffs WITH Peyton.

But sure let's compare the greatest offensive team of Brady's career to the worst Colts team since 99 and say that shows Brady was overrated. Like do you guys really expect anyone to take you serious when you act purposefully obtuse?

or MAYBE you guys just don't watch football games. This is Tom fukkin Brady who led the NFL in passing yards with Deion Branch and David fukking Givens and average WRs like that, go ahead and put Matt Cassel on THAT team.

How about we give Matt Cassel the 2004 Colts offense with Edge, Marvin and Reggie in their primes and then see what would happen. :what:

There's an argument for Peyton, but using that shyt automatically disqualifies your opinion, it shows ignorance of history and context. That's really just my two cents on the subject because I'm not evaluating them again until their done.

:obamaword:@that defense argument though, you're going to say shyt when Brady had throw a completion record in that shoot out vs. the Panthers. Get out.
Great QB's make bad teams look good which is what Peyton did in Indy. I just don't see Brady winning 12- 15 games with an Indy team that would win 1 game without Peyton Manning. Remember Peyton is not only the QB, he is basically the O-Coordinator on the team.
 
Last edited by a moderator:

FTBS

Superstar
Joined
May 29, 2012
Messages
19,611
Reputation
3,270
Daps
52,969
Reppin
NULL
The funniest shyt I read in here is that Brady magically got better once he got Moss and Welker. :dead:

No, dummies, his numbers got better, Brady was just as trill as ever. Brady finally getting weapons and then setting the league on fire proved our assertions correct: Tom Brady > Peyton Manning.

And like Manning he didn't win shyt with those weapons. Ironically enough putting up regular season numbers and then having those numbers drop come playoff time as your team cops Ls has long been used as a reason to downgrade Peyton. Now that it is Thomas of course nikkas will give you a thorough rundown of every play and how it isnt' Thomas' fault whereas before it was all about the bottom line. They are the same guy. :comeon: nikkas are entitled to their preference but I have really seen nothing from either to truly distinguish them from each other.
 

Street Knowledge

Superstar
Supporter
Joined
May 2, 2012
Messages
24,856
Reputation
1,948
Daps
59,667
Reppin
NYC
The funniest shyt I read in here is that Brady magically got better once he got Moss and Welker. :dead:

No, dummies, his numbers got better, Brady was just as trill as ever. Brady finally getting weapons and then setting the league on fire proved our assertions correct: Tom Brady > Peyton Manning.

nikkaz forget brady lead the league in TD's in 02' with a recieving core of

WR Troy Brown
-WR David Patten
-WR Deion Branch (Rookie)
-TE Christian Fauria

:stopitslime:

And yards in 05' with

Deion Branch
David Givens
Troy brown

:stopitslime:

Brady doesn't need elite Recievers to put up elite numbers

Nobody can find worse recieving cores a QB has lead the league in TD's or yards with. EVER
 

FTBS

Superstar
Joined
May 29, 2012
Messages
19,611
Reputation
3,270
Daps
52,969
Reppin
NULL
The first sentence was dedicated you, it was all inclusive about cats making dishonest arguments and you dapped up some of their comments so why wouldn't I include you?

Because it had nothing to do with me. :wtf: Nothing you said in there references anything I said. The fukk...we monitoring daps now? :heh: I didn't know that dapping a nikka meant that you cosigned EVERYTHING they said. I clearly quoted and bolded the part that I agreed with.
 
Top