Who's the better Quarterback? And whos career was better? Tom Brady or Peyton Manning
- Thread starter SpittinThatKnowledge
- Start date
Tom Brady, Patriots, 2007
Regular season (16-0): 398 of 578, 68.9%, 4,806 yards, 8.3 YPA, 50 TD, 8 INT, 117.2 passer rating
Peyton Manning, Colts, 2004
Regular season (12-4): 336 of 497, 67.6%, 4,557 yards, 9.2 YPA, 49 TD, 10 INT, 121.1 rating
The FIRST year Brady got serious weapons, he literally blew the doors off Peyton's best season.(Still the second best season a QB's ever had)
More yards, more TD's, less picks, higher Completion percentage, Perfect record, and the GOAT offense
Throwing the ball 81 more times to get 1 more TD and 249 more yards....
....WITH RANDALL GENE MOSS! Get over it...Peyton is the better QB while Thomas has played for the better team/organization. If you take a look at how much of Brady's postseason success has depended on other people than him, you'd realize this. Viniteri in the snow, Viniteri against the Rams, Carolina kicker kicking the damn KICKOFF outta bounds, Viniteri against the Panthers....hell even the Ravens blowing last years game! Or how he and Montana...and I wanna say Bradshaw are the only QB's to win a playoff game while throwing 3ints (like he did against the Chargers in the AFC title game a few years back. Manning doesn't have that window for error. If Manning is off, the team more than likely loses. Give me Peyton!Can we not have this debate ever again until they retire?
But I'll just drop this in here as my only comment.
Tom Brady was picked as QB of the decade over Peyton Manning. Aaron Rodgers, "Tom's better than all those guys." Just let the players tell it. I still think people can't wrap their heads around how an unheralded 6th round pick got to be so good.
Here's my question, why couldn't Bellicheck make another Brady in Cleveland? Why couldn't he make Pro Bowler and top 10 NFL QB Drew Bledsoe into Brady? Especially since Bledsoe was more physically talented as thrower than Brady? Why was he 5-14 with Bledsoe? Why couldn't Charlie Weis make another Brady? Brady led the NFL in passing yards right after Weis left, Cassel didn't do shyt. Bledsoe played better in Buffalo the very next year. Why did the Pats go from a bottom 10 offense in 2000 to top 6 in 2001 with Tom Brady at the helm? With juggernaut weapons on offense like...ugh.......David Patten
Why did Brady have to lead 4 4th quarter comebacks as a basically a rookie and 5 game winning drives that season? 
Why hasn't anyone made another Tom Brady? Oh yeah, that's right.
There isn't one.
But I'll just drop this in here as my only comment.
Tom Brady was picked as QB of the decade over Peyton Manning. Aaron Rodgers, "Tom's better than all those guys." Just let the players tell it. I still think people can't wrap their heads around how an unheralded 6th round pick got to be so good.
Here's my question, why couldn't Bellicheck make another Brady in Cleveland? Why couldn't he make Pro Bowler and top 10 NFL QB Drew Bledsoe into Brady? Especially since Bledsoe was more physically talented as thrower than Brady? Why was he 5-14 with Bledsoe? Why couldn't Charlie Weis make another Brady? Brady led the NFL in passing yards right after Weis left, Cassel didn't do shyt. Bledsoe played better in Buffalo the very next year. Why did the Pats go from a bottom 10 offense in 2000 to top 6 in 2001 with Tom Brady at the helm? With juggernaut weapons on offense like...ugh.......David Patten
Why did Brady have to lead 4 4th quarter comebacks as a basically a rookie and 5 game winning drives that season? Why hasn't anyone made another Tom Brady? Oh yeah, that's right.There isn't one.
Snitchin Splatter
Working With The Feds
11-5 without Brady 
2-14 without Peyton
Conversation over
2-14 without Peyton
Conversation over
Can we not have this debate ever again until they retire?
But I'll just drop this in here as my only comment.
Tom Brady was picked as QB of the decade over Peyton Manning. Aaron Rodgers, "Tom's better than all those guys." Just let the players tell it. I still think people can't wrap their heads around how an unheralded 6th round pick got to be so good.
Here's my question, why couldn't Bellicheck make another Brady in Cleveland? Why couldn't he make Pro Bowler and top 10 NFL QB Drew Bledsoe into Brady? Especially since Bledsoe was more physically talented as thrower than Brady? Why was he 5-14 with Bledsoe? Why couldn't Charlie Weis make another Brady? Brady led the NFL in passing yards right after Weis left, Cassel didn't do shyt. Bledsoe played better in Buffalo the very next year. Why did the Pats go from a bottom 10 offense in 2000 to top 6 in 2001 with Tom Brady at the helm? With juggernaut weapons on offense like...ugh.......David Patten
There isn't one.
Ask the players??? Let's ask
why he didn't punt on 4th down deep in his end a few years ago against the Colts?? Brady isn't a bum. Of course they can't make another one. But as long as Trent Dilfer is sporting a ring, a coach doesn't have to "make" another Brady to acheive TEAM success. Bragging about Brady's TEAM rings as the lone standard is lazy. You wanna listen to the players so much, listen to how players and coaches GAME PLAN to beat them. With Peyton, keep him on the sideline. With Thomas, get pressure with the front four without blitzing. Check how much actual time Peyton stayed on the sideline against the Saints. Not game time...ACTUAL TIME. At one point he was on the sideline for an hour straight. The most rushing attempts and largest time of possession stat this year for Thomas very own Patriots....came against Peyton and the Broncos.
Snitchin Splatter
Working With The Feds
Patriots fans will be quick to say Brady > Manning for the simple ring arrgument.
But as soon as you hit them with the "O, So Terry Bradshaw is clearly better than Tom Brady? " They get that
look in their eyes.
Instant ether
But as soon as you hit them with the "O, So Terry Bradshaw is clearly better than Tom Brady?
" They get that
Instant ether