Who's the better Quarterback? And whos career was better? Tom Brady or Peyton Manning

[Savior]

Ill take Brady any day...the only thing Manning had over him was regular season success. Then Brady got Moss and u saw what happened. Besides Moss Brady never had a receiver half as good as murder marv or Wayne. Never had an RB half as good as Edge. His playoff performances havent been amazing recently but still shyts on Manning's overall playoff performance.

 

[Jplaya2023]

The GOAT Montana had the Jerry Rice to throw to. We gonna hold that against him? How about Elway when he road Terrell to those two SB wins.

If Tyree's helmet didn't make that catch or Asante caught that INT in 07, plus the pass that Welker dropped last year, Brady would be undisputed GOAT. But all that shyt is part of the game breh. Just like Adam hitting those FGs, Rex Grossman throwing passes to Colts defenders in the SB, and Peyton hitting Porter for a clutch TD pass late in the SB

Joe Montana was a 2 time SB MVP while jerry rice was in highschool/college

 

[DStyles]

Tom Brady w/o a doubt.

Even if Adam Vinatieri "won" those three Super Bowls, you can knock Brady's hustle.

I cried when I watched The Brady 6

@ Eli's older brother.

 

[The Informant]

brady

 

[protestor]

Lol, so he goes to the Pro Bowl with lesser receivers than he had in New England and you still want to act like he was always playing at the same level.

This is why you clowns can't be taken seriously. You'll throw hard cold facts out the window just so you can keep repeating the same nonsense over and over.

im not ignoring anything, goof. matt cassel has always sucked. he sucked in NE, and he sucks now. hes a dude that had a couple of good season because of perfect conditions.

I'll give you cold facts


has a first good year despite never starting a game 6 years. he benefited in NE because of great wrs, oline - and coaching. . fact

he sucked when he went to the chiefs - fact

his second season there was decent he went to the to the Pro Bowl as dam alternate because brady was injured - fact

that same season jamal charles beasted 6.8 avg ypc. you give any QB 6.8 avg on first down. its a wrap. fact

charles went down the next year and surpirse! cassel "regressed". fact

he sucked in his third season - fact

hes one of the worst qb this season. fact

only way he has had any success is the conditions are perfect.

 

[Slaimon Khan Shah]

From what i've seen Manning is defintley the better Quarterback in my opinion.

 

[SpittinThatKnowledge]

Peyton for MVP?

 

[Johnny Kilroy]

Peyton is the better passer, Brady is the better QB, as illustrated by his better career.

 

[Born2BKing]

Peyton is the better passer, Brady is the better QB, as illustrated by his better career.

 

[Johnny Kilroy]

Damn I saw this special on PBS about epilepsy the other day. Good thing you ridin shotty and not driving.

 

[FTBS]

Peyton is the better passer, Brady is the better QB, as illustrated by his better career.

Would you still consider Brady a better QB if Vinateri missed those kicks in those SBs and the Pats ended up losing them with no change in Brady's performance?

 

[FLORIDA BOI]

brady

 

[Johnny Kilroy]

Would you still consider Brady a better QB if Vinateri missed those kicks in those SBs and the Pats ended up losing them with no change in Brady's performance?

How did Vinateri get in range?

This Brady/Peyton shyt really helped me understand what QBing is. I used to think Peyton was better hands down. But the QB is the General. What's the object in war? To win. Obviously the rest of the team helps but at the end of the day the QB's job is to make sure his team has more points on the board than the other team.

There's a reason QB's get W-L attached to them. That's not a coincidence or a mistake.

 

[FTBS]

How did Vinateri get in range?

This Brady/Peyton shyt really helped me understand what QBing is. I used to think Peyton was better hands down. But the QB is the General. What's the object in war? To win. Obviously the rest of the team helps but at the end of the day the QB's job is to make sure his team has more points on the board than the other team.

There's a reason QB's get W-L attached to them. That's not a coincidence or a mistake.

So in your estimation Brady's Generaling has fallen off over the last 7 years?

And actually it is a mistake because it takes the multitude of other factors outside of QB's performance out of the equation (unless of course nikkas like a QB in which case they can rattle off all the reasons an L isn't his fault ).

 

[STAN JONES]

The answer to both questions is Tom Brady

IMO they both are top 3 of all time tho