Which 2015 lottery picks can still become breakout stars?
Aside from
Kristaps Porzingis and
Karl-Anthony Towns, the top of the 2015 draft has been difficult to project through two NBA seasons.
Myles Turner and
Devin Booker have turned out to be draft day steals, but elite high school class of 2014 prospects
D'Angelo Russell,
Stanley Johnson and
Justise Winslow have had dramatic peaks and valleys during the early stages of their careers. (Jahlil Okafor, Emmanuel Mudiay and Mario Hezonja have also disappointed as they enter make-or-break seasons. We'll assess their futures in Pt. II).
How big of a role has team situation and infrastructure played in the lack of productivity and development of the once-heralded prep stars? Why exactly has each prospect stumbled thus far, and how much optimism should there be moving forward?
First-round picks from 2015 become extension eligible next July, making it imperative for teams to determine why these prospects have underwhelmed relative to expectations, and whether or not they should invest in them long term.
D'Angelo Russell | PG/SG | Brooklyn Nets
Player type: Smooth combo guard
Strengths that haven't translated
Transition: A creative, prolific open floor passer at Ohio State (35 percent of his assists came in transition), Russell has yet to push with as much aggression and lead an up-tempo offense at the NBA level as the Lakers finished 24th in open-court efficiency last season.
Shooting consistency: Russell's 35.1 percent rate from 3 (down from 41.1 at OSU) ranked 34th among 49 guards to start at least 50 games last season.
Pick-and-roll scoring: Produced 0.91 points per possession (91st percentile) at Ohio State, yet finished in the 41st percentile last season, largely due to his lack of explosiveness and streaky shooting.
Concerns that held up
Creating and finishing: Questions about his burst, leaping ability, off hand and physicality held true as he relied heavily on tough pull-ups and shot only 48.3 percent (20th percentile) at the rim last season.
Defensive intensity: Issues buying in on the defensive end continued in L.A., and Russell lacks the elite athleticism to make up for the lack of intensity.
Point guard polish: Lackadaisical nature, dribble-heavy style and struggles protecting the ball showed up against pressure, which begs the question: is Russell best on the ball?
Situational factor
Russell didn't do himself any favors in L.A. with his subpar work habits, but the Lakers were far from stable when the No. 2 pick arrived. Would Russell have had such a hard time adjusting to NBA life if he were drafted by the
San Antonio Spurs? The same could be said for most any young prospect, but between Byron Scott's old-school style, the Kobe farewell tour, the
Nick Young saga and the front office's dysfunction, the Lakers were far from the model of stability. Although Russell could have done much more to focus on development despite the distractions, the work environment was sub-optimal.
Reasons for optimism/pessimism
Russell still has immense offensive value, even if he may never be a two-way star. He's comfortable on or off the ball, plays with extreme savvy as both a scorer and playmaker in ball screens and has the shooting touch to become a more consistent factor from the perimeter, already having made 3.0 3s per 40 minutes last season. The fact that he's a below-average athlete and so reliant on contested pull-ups and difficult floaters makes his margin for error much slimmer, though.
The Nets want to play fast, and the developmentally focused Kenny Atkinson should be good for Russell long term. Playing next to a high IQ, veteran guard like
Jeremy Lin will help cover up some of Russell's deficiencies. Finding ways to play with consistent vigor, limit careless turnovers and take on more of a leadership role on a Nets team still searching for direction will be key. He's too talented not to pop off for 40-plus on occasion or string together
highlight-reel spin passes through traffic, but can he do it consistently and help Brooklyn win? Will the off-court distractions that slowed him in L.A. continue to impede his progress in New York?
How he answers those questions will determine his future value and how the Nets organization sees him moving forward. Even in a league loaded with gifted point guards, Russell remains a starting-caliber guard with the talent to develop into much more if he can buy into maximizing his potential.
Stanley Johnson | SF/PF | Detroit Pistons
Player type: Two-way combo forward
Strengths that haven't translated
Shooting: Although never a true shooter at the youth level, Johnson's 37.1 percent clip at Arizona was encouraging. But he has really struggled from the NBA line -- below 30 percent from 3 while finishing in the 29th percentile off the catch and 33rd percentile off the dribble last season.
Slashing: Once an aggressive downhill slasher, Johnson attempted 0.46 free throws per field goal at Arizona, but that number dropped dramatically to 0.16 last season, which ranked in the bottom 40 among NBA players to see at least 15 MPG.
Rebounding: Early in his high school career Johnson got on the floor as an energy rebounder (14.1 boards per 40 minutes in 2013 EYBL), but he has really tailed off in that area, grabbing only 5.5 per 40 last season.
Concerns that held up
Finishing: Below-the-rim athlete who shot only 43.8 percent at the basket with the Wildcats and 51 percent last season with the Pistons (27th percentile).
Decision-making: Johnson can become a quicker thinker on the floor, eliminating the catch-and-hold in his game and better playing within a flow, since he does have sound vision.
Defensive consistency: Can continue to develop more of a lockdown-defender mentality while letting his offense come to him.
Situational factor
Johnson had a rocky start to his NBA career. His mother, a former overseas pro and prominent figure in California basketball circles who wore every hat
from mom to coach to mentor to disciplinarian, passed away the summer going into his rookie season. His up-and-down play and sometimes inconsistent approach has had him in and out of head coach Stan Van Gundy's doghouse. The former Mater Dei Prep star had been more or less "the man" at every level prior to the NBA, and Van Gundy's tough love approach didn't always sit well. The fact that the Pistons have played the 240-plus pound Johnson at almost exclusively the 2 and the 3 also hasn't done him any favors spacing wise, as the heralded youth star has more than adequate size to play the 4 in today's NBA.
Reasons for optimism/pessimism
Despite his up and down two seasons in Detroit, Johnson fits the mold of what every NBA team is looking for in a combo forward. Only so many 6-6, 240-pounders with a 7-foot wingspan exist, and very few have the offensive potential and defensive versatility that Johnson has shown flashes of. According to the DraftExpress database (dating back to 2000), Johnson is the only perimeter player under 6-7 to weigh at least 240 pounds with a wingspan greater than 6-11.
There's no question he needs to play with more steady toughness and shoot the ball better, but NBA teams would be wise to monitor Johnson closely moving forward, seeing him as more of a power wing and small-ball 4 than he has played in Detroit. He has shooting potential with sharp footwork and a fairly quick release from the corners. He's comfortable handling in ball screens, a capable passer in quick actions and has the physical profile that teams want in a stretch wing who can switch every screen and take a run at guarding power wings like LeBron. Johnson would struggle less with hard contests given his low release point if he played up a position.
Expect Johnson to take a big step in production and reliability with an increased role this season, likely starting next to
Avery Bradley and
Reggie Jackson. If Johnson can put his Ron Artest-like physical profile to use defensively and rediscover the traits that made him such a highly touted recruit at a young age while shooting the ball better, he could very well bounce back in a big way and become one of the more coveted 21-year-old combo forwards in the East.
Justise Winslow | PF/C | Miami Heat
Player type: Modern defend, slash and pass PF/C
Strengths that haven't translated
Spot shooting: Scouts still had major questions about Winslow's jumper, but his 25.7 career 3-point percentage is a far cry from his 41.4 percent mark while playing the 4 at Duke.
Finishing: Lighter and more explosive in Durham (55.5 percent at the rim), Winslow has bulked up considerably and struggled to adjust to NBA length and athleticism, shooting only 46.3 percent at the rim last season.
Rebounding: Winslow's rebounding percentage has dipped from 13.0 percent at Duke to 8.3 percent last season.
Concern that held up
Half-court scoring: Made only 1-of-20 inside the arc jumpers and 4-of-21 floaters at Duke and has had similar troubles scoring in the NBA, averaging 9.3 points per 40 minutes as a rookie and 12.5 per 40 last season.
Situational factor
Unlike his counterparts, Winslow landed in an excellent situation with a strong organization and a competitive team that featured a healthy blend of veterans and young players. With Erik Spoelstra willing to play Winslow at the 4 and 5, the former Blue Devil was able to focus on his ready-made skills to impact winning without worrying about scoring. However, Winslow is coming off a poor statistical season hampered by injuries in 2016-17 (18 games played).
Reasons for optimism/pessimism
Although he's no
Draymond Green, there are very few players who can legitimately defend 1 through 5 and pass like a point guard on the other end. Winslow is in a great position to continue to learn from an excellent coach, grow with a fairly young group and develop his scoring while impacting the game in all of the same ways that made him a prep star years ago.
There's no doubt that Winslow's jumper needs a whole lot of work, and his confidence in it appears very fractured. Defenders help off of the strong side corner when he's spotting up, and go under every screen or dribble handoff when he's on the ball. Winslow finished last in the NBA in catch-and-shoot efficiency last season, going 9-for-45 in such situations. But even with his glaring scoring limitations, the Houston native may be the most likely of these 2015 draftees to maximize his potential long term.
He can grab and go in transition, playmake out of ball screens with an impressive handle, unique wiggle and excellent vision and check the intangible boxes as a cutter and offensive rebounder. Even if Winslow never becomes a reliable 3-point shooter, he'll still have value as a defend-everyone, slash-pass-and-cut style modern 4/5 as traditional centers have had trouble moving the rugged forward on the block. If he can become at least respectable from 3? Miami will be doing everything in its power to extend Winslow long term come July 1.