NFC WEST
Arizona Cardinals
Post-draft grade: B-
Based on production this new grade should probably be lower, but there's still a decent amount of potential here, and you could certainly make a case for several of the picks from a planning perspective. Remember, at the time the Cardinals were a good team trying to add talent at logical places. We just didn't see the Cardinals falling off so much in 2016, but a lot of that had to do with quarterback play, not these picks. As for the guys they got, there are question marks.
Robert Nkemdiche was a top-10 talent who dropped because of attitude concerns, and those popped up. Head coach Bruce Arians called him out at least once and used the word "maturity" in doing so. From a planning perspective, Nkemdiche made sense and could be a steal, because Calais Campbell was likely on his way out and now is in Jacksonville. Maybe Nkemdiche becomes a great player (he can be), given the starting role Campbell held for years. Brandon Williams was bound to struggle, given that he'd spent time at running back in college. But he has ability and can improve. We'll see about Evan Boehm, but he could start at right guard in 2017. This feels like an "incomplete" grade right now. Let's hope Nkemdiche comes hungry next season.
New grade: C+
Round/Pick Name Pos College
1/29 Robert Nkemdiche DT Ole Miss
3/92 Brandon Williams CB Texas A&M
4/128 Evan Boehm G Missouri
5/167 Marqui Christian S Midwestern State University
5/170 Cole Toner OT Harvard
6/205 Harlan Miller CB SE Louisiana
Los Angeles Rams
Post-draft grade: B-
I suspect a lot of people think I should hammer this draft class, given Jared Goff's first-year struggles, but there's a problem with that: We said all along that Goff would struggle early on based on the system he was coming from at Cal and the lack of help on this Rams roster, so should we be surprised? I wrote at the time, "I'm a fan of Goff ... [but] they'll need to be extremely patient and find ways to protect him." When Goff played, the Rams had no running game to take pressure off him and didn't pass protect well, and his receivers were a parade of dropped passes, including some that bounced off hands and chests and right to a defender for a pick. Does this look good so far? Of course not. Is it all because of Goff? No way.
After Goff, that's just about it. They like Tyler Higbee's potential, but he had just 11 catches. Same story with Pharoh Cooper, who had 14. It's all about Goff at this point. I just hope he gets a real shot -- and some help.
New grade: C
Round/Pick Name Pos College
1/1 Jared Goff QB California
4/110 Tyler Higbee TE Western Kentucky
4/117 Pharoh Cooper WR South Carolina
6/177 Temarrick Hemingway TE South Carolina State
6/190 Josh Forrest ILB Kentucky
6/206 Michael Thomas WR Southern Mississippi
San Francisco 49ers
Post-draft grade: C
A lot has changed since then-GM Trent Baalke and then-coach Chip Kelly were running point. If the re-grade seems harsh, just remember how bad this team was in 2016. You expect rookies to make contributions to a team this bad, but then the return was pretty lean. So far DeForest Buckner looks like a pretty decent pro. He started 15 games and moved around a lot, and he picked up six sacks and 73 tackles. I didn't like the Joshua Garnett pick, because if you trade up for a guard I hope it's not a reach on value. Garnett started the final 11 games at right guard but struggled a great deal.
After that, there just isn't much. Will Redmond didn't play, and Ronald Blair had some flashes (three sacks) and will be pass-rush depth in 2017. There isn't much to speak of after that, aside from part-time work for Rashard Robinson. If Buckner becomes a really good player and Garnett gets better, this class looks a little better. But the returns were pretty light in 2016.
New grade: C-
Round/Pick Name Pos College
1/7 DeForest Buckner DE Oregon
1/28 Joshua Garnett G Stanford
3/68 Will Redmond CB Mississippi State
4/133 Rashard Robinson CB Louisiana State
5/142 Ronald Blair DT Appalachian State
5/145 John Theus OT Georgia
5/174 Fahn Cooper OT Ole Miss
6/207 Jeff Driskel QB Louisiana Tech
6/211 Kelvin Taylor RB Florida
6/213 Aaron Burbridge WR Michigan State
7/249 Prince Charles Iworah CB Western Kentucky
Seattle Seahawks
Post-draft grade: B+
I liked the players Seattle got for the most part, including one big steal, but the fact that some of them had to play such prominent roles was a problem. Germain Ifedi was a good pick, but as I said then, he was going to have to transition from tackle to guard, and that doesn't just happen with a snap of the fingers. I give the Seahawks credit for finding undrafted free agent George Fant, but when a guy not far removed from the basketball court is protecting Russell Wilson's blind side, that's not a good thing. Ifedi and Fant should get better, but they struggled last season.
But again, there's a lot to like. Jarran Reed was a steal on my board, and he got eight starts as part of the rotation on the defensive interior, and I like his potential to do more. C.J. Prosise looked good, but health questions are going to linger. Nick Vannett saw some time and could play a bigger role going forward. Alex Collins got a few carries, though it's now a full backfield. Undrafted free agent Trevone Boykin could be an effective backup. Overall, that's a good return for one of the five or six best teams in the league. You just hope the O-linemen develop.
New grade: B
Round/Pick Name Pos College
1/31 Germain Ifedi OT Texas A&M
2/49 Jarran Reed DT Alabama
3/90 C.J. Prosise RB Notre Dame
3/94 Nick Vannett TE Ohio State
3/97 Rees Odhiambo G Boise State
5/147 Quinton Jefferson DT Maryland
5/171 Alex Collins RB Arkansas
6/215 Joey Hunt C TCU
7/243 Kenny Lawler WR California
7/247 Zac Brooks RB Clemson
Arizona Cardinals
Post-draft grade: B-
Based on production this new grade should probably be lower, but there's still a decent amount of potential here, and you could certainly make a case for several of the picks from a planning perspective. Remember, at the time the Cardinals were a good team trying to add talent at logical places. We just didn't see the Cardinals falling off so much in 2016, but a lot of that had to do with quarterback play, not these picks. As for the guys they got, there are question marks.
Robert Nkemdiche was a top-10 talent who dropped because of attitude concerns, and those popped up. Head coach Bruce Arians called him out at least once and used the word "maturity" in doing so. From a planning perspective, Nkemdiche made sense and could be a steal, because Calais Campbell was likely on his way out and now is in Jacksonville. Maybe Nkemdiche becomes a great player (he can be), given the starting role Campbell held for years. Brandon Williams was bound to struggle, given that he'd spent time at running back in college. But he has ability and can improve. We'll see about Evan Boehm, but he could start at right guard in 2017. This feels like an "incomplete" grade right now. Let's hope Nkemdiche comes hungry next season.
New grade: C+
Round/Pick Name Pos College
1/29 Robert Nkemdiche DT Ole Miss
3/92 Brandon Williams CB Texas A&M
4/128 Evan Boehm G Missouri
5/167 Marqui Christian S Midwestern State University
5/170 Cole Toner OT Harvard
6/205 Harlan Miller CB SE Louisiana
Los Angeles Rams
Post-draft grade: B-
I suspect a lot of people think I should hammer this draft class, given Jared Goff's first-year struggles, but there's a problem with that: We said all along that Goff would struggle early on based on the system he was coming from at Cal and the lack of help on this Rams roster, so should we be surprised? I wrote at the time, "I'm a fan of Goff ... [but] they'll need to be extremely patient and find ways to protect him." When Goff played, the Rams had no running game to take pressure off him and didn't pass protect well, and his receivers were a parade of dropped passes, including some that bounced off hands and chests and right to a defender for a pick. Does this look good so far? Of course not. Is it all because of Goff? No way.
After Goff, that's just about it. They like Tyler Higbee's potential, but he had just 11 catches. Same story with Pharoh Cooper, who had 14. It's all about Goff at this point. I just hope he gets a real shot -- and some help.
New grade: C
Round/Pick Name Pos College
1/1 Jared Goff QB California
4/110 Tyler Higbee TE Western Kentucky
4/117 Pharoh Cooper WR South Carolina
6/177 Temarrick Hemingway TE South Carolina State
6/190 Josh Forrest ILB Kentucky
6/206 Michael Thomas WR Southern Mississippi
San Francisco 49ers
Post-draft grade: C
A lot has changed since then-GM Trent Baalke and then-coach Chip Kelly were running point. If the re-grade seems harsh, just remember how bad this team was in 2016. You expect rookies to make contributions to a team this bad, but then the return was pretty lean. So far DeForest Buckner looks like a pretty decent pro. He started 15 games and moved around a lot, and he picked up six sacks and 73 tackles. I didn't like the Joshua Garnett pick, because if you trade up for a guard I hope it's not a reach on value. Garnett started the final 11 games at right guard but struggled a great deal.
After that, there just isn't much. Will Redmond didn't play, and Ronald Blair had some flashes (three sacks) and will be pass-rush depth in 2017. There isn't much to speak of after that, aside from part-time work for Rashard Robinson. If Buckner becomes a really good player and Garnett gets better, this class looks a little better. But the returns were pretty light in 2016.
New grade: C-
Round/Pick Name Pos College
1/7 DeForest Buckner DE Oregon
1/28 Joshua Garnett G Stanford
3/68 Will Redmond CB Mississippi State
4/133 Rashard Robinson CB Louisiana State
5/142 Ronald Blair DT Appalachian State
5/145 John Theus OT Georgia
5/174 Fahn Cooper OT Ole Miss
6/207 Jeff Driskel QB Louisiana Tech
6/211 Kelvin Taylor RB Florida
6/213 Aaron Burbridge WR Michigan State
7/249 Prince Charles Iworah CB Western Kentucky
Seattle Seahawks
Post-draft grade: B+
I liked the players Seattle got for the most part, including one big steal, but the fact that some of them had to play such prominent roles was a problem. Germain Ifedi was a good pick, but as I said then, he was going to have to transition from tackle to guard, and that doesn't just happen with a snap of the fingers. I give the Seahawks credit for finding undrafted free agent George Fant, but when a guy not far removed from the basketball court is protecting Russell Wilson's blind side, that's not a good thing. Ifedi and Fant should get better, but they struggled last season.
But again, there's a lot to like. Jarran Reed was a steal on my board, and he got eight starts as part of the rotation on the defensive interior, and I like his potential to do more. C.J. Prosise looked good, but health questions are going to linger. Nick Vannett saw some time and could play a bigger role going forward. Alex Collins got a few carries, though it's now a full backfield. Undrafted free agent Trevone Boykin could be an effective backup. Overall, that's a good return for one of the five or six best teams in the league. You just hope the O-linemen develop.
New grade: B
Round/Pick Name Pos College
1/31 Germain Ifedi OT Texas A&M
2/49 Jarran Reed DT Alabama
3/90 C.J. Prosise RB Notre Dame
3/94 Nick Vannett TE Ohio State
3/97 Rees Odhiambo G Boise State
5/147 Quinton Jefferson DT Maryland
5/171 Alex Collins RB Arkansas
6/215 Joey Hunt C TCU
7/243 Kenny Lawler WR California
7/247 Zac Brooks RB Clemson