2016 MLB draft: AL team-by-team breakdown
After posting the summaries and opinions of the first 10 rounds of the MLB draft for all 15 National League teams yesterday, today I have the AL team-by-team breakdown.
As I've stated in previous years, I don't do "winners and losers," a fool's exercise in the baseball draft. Instead, I tell you what I liked and didn't like for each team, and highlight players of note. To see the full Draft Tracker for Rounds 1-10, click here. I've also added a few players taken after the 10th round if they're notable and I think there's a reasonable chance they'll sign.
A few relevant notes:
• The number in parentheses indicates the round in which that player was selected.
• When I refer to "my rankings," I'm referring to my Big Board, my top 100 draft prospects, which can be found here.
• I also wrote about the highlights of Round 1 and Round 2, and Eric Longenhagen had pick-by-pick analysis of Round 1 through the competitive balance Round A, then round-by-round analysis of Rounds 2-10.
• If we have scouting profiles of the player mentioned, his name will link to his profile, written by Eric Longenhagen.
• We use the 20-80 grading scale for all MLB prospects.
Baltimore Orioles
Prep right-hander Brenan Hanifee (4) is a huge projection gamble, a very athletic kid with feel to pitch and a good delivery but fringy present stuff; he's a "double-projection" guy with big upside if the velocity comes. … Alexis Torres(5) might be a good value pick here, as he was a potential top-100 guy coming into the spring but performed poorly at the plate, losing his approach and visibly pressing at times. He's listed as a shortstop but probably ends up at second base. … Tobias Myers (6) is a 6-foot high school right-hander with a very quick arm, 90-92, touching 94, with a solid-average changeup and some depth on a slow curveball. … Preston Palmeiro (7) has the famous finger-pointing father but didn't inherit the hit gene and will probably be a good organizational bat.
Boston Red Sox
The Red Sox took CJ Chatham (2) out of Florida Atlantic with the 51st overall pick, a reach for me given that he probably won't remain at shortstop and has too little power for another position. … Florida closer Shaun Anderson (3) is a three-pitch guy who could convert to starting, although I think he's probably a reliever in the long run due to the lack of a plus pitch when he starts. He does have the command and control for any role and could move very quickly through the minors as a reliever. … Bobby Dalbec (4) is a third baseman and reliever for the University of Arizona with 80 power and a 70 arm, but he struck out 76 times in 250 plate appearances this spring and may be a better prospect on the mound, where he's 92-95 with a surprisingly good delivery and a sharp slider. He also threw 126 pitches in Arizona's super regional this weekend after spending nearly all of the season working in short stints for the Wildcats, which had to thrill the Red Sox. I've never bought his plate discipline or approach at the plate, but there is absolutely 30-homer power in there. … The Red Sox did take one more potential over-slot guy in Las Vegas prep shortstop Nick Quintana (11), who was probably a third-round talent. He can hit with plus bat speed, but he's not a shortstop, so he either has to move to second or try to convert to catcher.
Chicago White Sox
Alex Call (3) is an undersized hitter from Ball State who profiles as a fourth outfielder due to a lack of power. … Jameson Fisher (4) is a 22½-year-old senior who put up comical numbers for Southeastern Louisiana University this year, but he's limited to first base due to below-average speed and arm strength, and those stats came against weak pitching in the Southland Conference this year. (As far as I can tell, the Southland saw one pitcher drafted through the top 20 rounds this year, a lefty taken in the 16th.) … Jimmy LambertLuis Curbelo (6), who moved to Florida and played at Cocoa High School, will have to move to second or third but has good feel to hit and future average power.
Cleveland Indians
Logan Ice (2A) is a bit of a sleeper, a very strong defensive catcher who couldn't do anything offensively before this spring, when he hit .310/.432/.563 for Oregon State. Before 2016, he didn't seem to have the strength to profile as even an average hitter, let alone having any power. That said, it won't take much offense for him to profile as an everyday catcher. … Aaron Civale (3) put up good numbers for Northeastern this year, but he's a bad-bodied 6-foot-1 right-hander who tops out at 91 with an average slider. He projects as an org starter or middle reliever. … Shane Bieber (4) may have his "beliebers" thanks to only 37 walks in 285 career innings for UC Santa Barbara, but he pitches with a grade-45 fastball and a fringy slider. This could (or should) be a money-saver to reallocate bonus pool money to the first two picks … or to Conner Capel (5), a fairly toolsy center fielder from a Houston-area high school who can run, field and throw but needs to get stronger to hit enough for everyday duty. He just turned 19 a few weeks ago, so he's an older high school kid, and he's committed to Texas. … Ulysses Cantu (6) is at the other end of the spectrum from Capel; he's strong, can hit and has some power, but has no position. He'll go out at third base but needs work there; he caught some this year in high school, but Cleveland has no plans to leave him there. … Kansas catcherMichael Tinsley (7) is like the yin to Logan Ice's yang, a solid hitter who never strikes out, but other than arm strength, he doesn't do anything even average behind the plate and will be a project back there. I don't know if the team's plan was to pair up picks like that -- Benson/Jones, Capel/Cantu, Ice/Tinsley -- but I like the portfolio it forms.