Where Colin Kaepernick should land if the 49ers cut ties
Quarterback
Colin Kaepernick needs a fresh start, a new teacher and a system that defies the stubborn old-school logic of the NFL. Talk that he is unable to adapt to the static world of the pro game is shortsighted and a product of coaches unwilling to think outside of the box. Kaepernick, despite his early success in the league, has taken a step back in his development as an NFL quarterback, but don't be so quick to dismiss him being a starter again some day.
Getting to that point would require dedication on Kaepernick's end to absorb new techniques -- and likely a willingness to begin this journey as a No. 2 guy in 2016. But it's not all on the QB. All player-coach relationships are two-way streets, and it would be up to Kaepernick's coaches to create a new learning curve for the QB, along with a system that meshes spread and pro-style concepts.
Thinking along those lines, here are a few teams and coaches who could facilitate Kaepernick's development next season, should the 49ers decide to go in a different direction.
Sando: It's easy to forget just how bright Kaepernick's future appeared when the 49ers signed him to a contract extension before their 2014 training camp. He had a 21-8 starting record with four postseason victories and a Super Bowl appearance. He ranked first in Total QBR, second in winning percentage and fourth in passer rating among 25 quarterbacks who made their first 29 starts over the previous nine seasons.
Was it all a mirage? Yes and no. The 49ers have imploded since Kaepernick signed his contract extension. Plans have changed. There are new coaches, a new offense and severely diminished personnel around him. The context that helped Kaepernick to succeed has dissolved.
one personnel director said. "It is really crazy because they paid him all that money. When Kaepernick was having success, they were doing the read-option, they were rolling him out, he was doing stuff like that. He has a strong arm and he is not terribly accurate, but when he had that threat of running, he was much better."
The dozens of NFL coaches and personnel evaluators I've polled regarding quarterbacks never thought Kaepernick would become an upper-tier drop-back passer. He was never accurate enough. His throwing mechanics were questionable. He had no training in a drop-back passing offense. Is age 28 the time to make Kaepernick into something few people, if any, ever thought he could become? That's a tough sell.
"History shows unless they can adapt and beat you from the pocket, they become Jake Locker," another personnel evaluator once told me, referencing the oft-injured former Titans quarterback. "Eventually, people will stop rushing
Russell Wilson and make him beat them from the pocket. Time tells if he can do that at 5-foot-10. My guess is that Kaepernick physically can. Whether the mental side will allow him to, I do not know."
No doubt, coaches and players (especially defensive backs) around the NFL respect quarterbacks who can beat them consistently as passers from the pocket. Dual-threat quarterbacks crave that respect. They naturally want to prove they can succeed without their legs. Has Kaepernick gone that route? That is difficult to prove statistically.
Before landing on the bench and injured reserve this season, Kaepernick was running the ball about as frequently as he had in the past. (See chart above.) His zone-read rushing attempts also had not fallen sharply. But with nearly all the 49ers' running backs injured, their offensive line (including tight ends) diminished and their defensive safety net gone, playing quarterback certainly became tougher for an unpolished passer in a new system. Other quarterbacks, including
Joe Flacco this season, have had issues when their support systems have fallen apart.
The surest way for Kaepernick to succeed again is for his 2016 team to recreate some of the conditions that existed for him previously. That means placing the quarterback in an offense with a ground game strong enough to compromise what opposing defenses can do to slow down a dual-threat quarterback.
Tony Romo? Houston, despite getting better-than-expected play from Hoyer this season, has a long-term need and a head coach in Bill O'Brien who comes from the Bill Belichick game-plan-of-the-week approach. Could Kaepernick have some appeal there?
Bowen: There are two important perspectives here. Let's start with the money angle. Kaepernick is making $12.8 million this season. And for him to come anywhere close to that figure in 2016 (assuming the 49ers release him), he'll have to be signed by a team that sees him as a possible long-term solution at quarterback, not a developmental project. Starting over as a No. 2? That's not quite as lucrative.
With that in mind, St. Louis and Houston both make a lot of sense. Neither team has a franchise quarterback, and both play with an old-school style: Run the ball, play defense and get the necessary production from the quarterback to win football games.
The trade to bring in
Nick Foles has been a bust for Jeff Fisher's team, and
Brian Hoyer isn't the quarterback to build around for the future in Houston under Bill O'Brien. Would the Rams or Texans adapt their systems to fit Kaepernick? That's up for debate, but the opportunity to start right away -- and make decent money -- might be there.
With Chip Kelly and the Eagles, the idea of bringing in Kaepernick is becoming a tired narrative, but I get it. Kelly's up-tempo style and play calling facilitates quick reads from the quarterback and also caters to an athletic guy who can run the ball on the zone-read concept. I could see Kelly and Kaepernick fitting well together if the two had an entire offseason to work together and mesh the QB's style with the Eagles' playbook.
Looking at the Cowboys, I would never doubt Jerry Jones when a high-profile name comes available. He's a business man first, and Kaepernick would sell in Big D. Plus, there has to be some concern over the future of Tony Romo. Given Romo's age and the injuries, the clock is ticking. That could be another landing spot that pays well on Kaepernick's list.
But let's take a step back here and focus on another key element: What coaches, other than Kelly, would provide the development that Kaepernick needs? If the QB finds someone who both plays to his strengths and is fully invested in harnessing his raw talent, the money will follow. Trust me.
Personally, I'd love to see Kaepernick team up with Adam Gase. The Bears' offensive coordinator has done an excellent job with
Jay Cutler this season. From the advanced mechanics Cutler has shown in the pocket to his ability to execute within the system, Gase has the Bears' much-maligned QB playing the best ball of his career.
Yeah, the overall numbers might not reflect that, but the tape really tells the story: Gase has taken one of the NFL's "gunslingers" and harnessed him to create a smarter and more effective player. The Bears, at times, reflect a college spread team with packaged plays, run-pass options, the wide receiver screen game and even the threat of the zone-read. And that, in turn, has put Cutler in a position to produce with limited weapons around him at the skill positions due to injury.
Tyrod Taylor, is signed for multiple seasons at a reasonable rate, so the team could sign Kaepernick for decent backup money and still remain under budget at the position. Taylor would be the starter based on how well he is playing. Kaepernick would provide insurance that seems badly needed given Taylor's inability to stay healthy and the Bills' inability to win games without him.
One important factor to remember, which Matt alluded to, is that several head coaching and coordinator jobs will turn over before next season, making projections difficult this far out.
There are some other details to consider, as well. Kaepernick's contract with San Francisco is scheduled to count $16.8 million against the 2016 salary cap. The team would still have to account for $7.4 million in cap charges even if Kaepernick were off the roster. The contract also gives the 49ers until April 1 -- weeks into free agency and the trading period -- to make a decision before future guarantees lock in. That means this drama could be playing out for some time.