The Ice Bowl, Part 2: The Official COWBOYS (#3) @ PACKERS (#2) NFC Divisional Playoffs Thread

[philmonroe]

Correct me if Im wrong.. how Green Bay get a second challenge anyway after they lost the first one?

They don't get a third challenge you always get two challenges.

 

[Danie84]

Cowgirls Tears>>>CaC Tears

 

[Big Boss]

dez like

 

[jdubnyce]

Cowgirls Tears>>>CaC Tears

cowgirls tears = cac tears

 

[You Win Perfect]

clearly a catch by dez. funny thing is if he woulda broke the goal line that woulda been a touchdown no matter what.


on another note, im done with the nfl. refs now using replay cameras to officiate games instead of their own eyes. booth review this, booth review that.

 

[Lord Beasley]

Ian fitz going in on the refs right now. The shyt was a catch. fukk toy Megatron !!

Dunno how it's imcomplete yet that one Cobb catch is complete.

 

[R.E.N. Spells Ren]

Again. A caught, secured, possessed ball completed the catch process while Dez took 2.5 steps if not 3 falling forward and outstretched his arm following the completed catch process to try to score.

Here's the thing, breh, if you interpret it that way, they made the correct call. Falling forward would require him to maintain possession throughout the catch....meaning, the ball can hit the ground if it doesn't move OR he can juggle it as long as it never touches the ground.

 

[R.E.N. Spells Ren]

clearly a catch by dez. funny thing is if he woulda broke the goal line that woulda been a touchdown no matter what.

Nope, that's not true.

 

[nieman]

Yes, he caught it, secured it, and possessed it...but then he didn't. You don't seem to understand the concept of "completing the catch". He didn't catch it on the run. He caught it in the air, and stumbled forward to the ground. That means he has to keep possession the entire time. When he hit the ground, the ball hit the ground and popped loose. I repeat, the ball HIT THE GROUND, and POPPED LOOSE. That's not maintaining possession. But if you've been watching football close enough the past few years, you already knew that, and you're arguing just to argue.

But him turning around, switching hands to secure it, taking steps, negates that. Calvin Johnson was in the air, all one continuous motion. Whether he lost his balance or dove, is the argument, but possession and steps were established prior to. I think he was going down, so tried to extend to goal line, with the secure hand. That's a catch, since he clearly took steps with the ball in possession. The challenge, if any, should have been down or fumble TD.

No one is arguing him having possession of the ball, or him taking steps, or even trying to extend to the goal line. So all of that is seemingly, unanimously agreed upon. The argument is him losing possession at the end of the play, and how is that argued as not having control throughout the end of the play..when everything NOT being argued is saying that he already had possession.

But in the end, the fix was in to unfix the prior fix.

 

[Danie84]

Cowgirls L got skip veins on a hundred, thousand, trillion

 

[Danie84]

Every Lions fan know we have been redeemed
7 Mile bytches!!

They got Papá Doc'd

 

[Darealtwo1]

Dez did run onto the field without his helmet on after the reversal. Once again, no flag was thrown.

 

[You Win Perfect]

Nope, that's not true.

he caught the ball switched hands put the other arm down and clearly lunged for the TD, if he broke the line it was TD

 

[Rich Spirit]

Dez dumb for trying to extend the ball

 

[Ain't That Something]

Look like I miss some good old cowboy fukkery