On second viewing I have more respect for what they did with Finn. The films weaknesses are in the editing, the overly kinetic nature of the plot and lets just call it what it is, the third death star, was just lazy or rushed writing. They overpowered Rey and Han Solo's death was treated with a minimal amount of care and respect. Leia's character is the weakest of all the mains which is a combination of carrie fisher's personal issues and lazy writing. She would have been better of dead to be honest. Hopefully they do something effective with her in ep VIII because she took me out of the experience completely. The technical elements of the film are nearly perfect but some of the sound effects were a little off.
The film had it's brilliant moments. The opening act was well done and our introduction to Rey and her sad scavenger life was fantastic. Jakku felt familiar but different. She reminded me much more of Anakin than Luke. I liked the Cantina bar on Maz' planet and I can see some extended universe adventures centered around her bar. Tales from Maz' cantina is something I would read. Speaking of Maz, she was the Yoda of this film but brutally underused. I thought Poe was funny but also brutally underused. Kylo Started off with so much promise but once the mask came off it was hit and miss the rest of the way. Chewie was GREAT. Han was mostly great and carried the middle acts of the film but like I said his death was not given it's due and some of his dialogue, especially the space-talk and techno-jargon felt shoehorned in as fan service. I didn't like all the shaky cam. Abrams is kind of like a dog that you love. You know what you are going to get with him but he just has to mark his territory and it felt like some of the shots were just him marking his JJ territory. A little shot here, a little shot there. In general I thought it was well directed and tight but there was a certain inconsistency which came through certain parts.
Having Finn say "Droid please" was a despicable thing to do. It's not funny and that type of phrase is not part of the SWU lexicon. No one in the film made reference to Finn's race except himself and he did it regularly which I am sure was a decision that came from on high. Maybe the writers were trying to disarm people who were a little uncomfortable with the casting so make them laugh, relax them and then he can be one of the guys...? I don't know but I hope they get rid of that shyt in the next one because it isn't necessary. I thought the line where he told Rey he was in the resistance and "resistance fighters look like me... but some of them look different" was enough to get the point across in a funny way and people in the theater really laughed at that one. I think there may have been multiple cuts of Finn and in audience testing they settled on the one that was least threatening and most disarming as if they needed to get the viewer on his side.
Kylo was more interesting when masked. He had some good moments unmasked but he lost much of what makes him scary and mysterious after the second interrogation scene. I like that he was a vader fanboy but I think they underpowered him and will need to have him become much more menacing in future films or he will have been a wasted opportunity.
I think they overpowered Rey making her adept at everything she tried. She never really gets made a fool of. In fact, they almost used the moments of ineptitude of the male cast to boost her into godlike status. I also think this was a decision that came from Disney's stooge Kathleen Kennedy. The story is really about Rey, probably Luke's daughter which is lazy writing imo, finally leaving home and accepting her destiny but the characters of Finn. Han, Kylo Ren and Luke all had to suffer for it. Almost like a push in wrestling. Rey is the Face and Finn and Kylo became jobbers who help get her over.
The comedy was clever and made TFA feel more like the Original Trilogy instead of the overly serious Prequel Trilogy. BB-8 was very clever and believable as a druid with personality. The first half was much stronger than the second half because it felt new while the second half felt like nothing but fan service done well. The ending provides a nice cliffhanger although that last overhead shot circling Luke and Rey was another case of JJ marking his territory.
In all I enjoyed it and it felt more like Star Wars than any of the prequels but I can also say Ewan McGregor in any of the prequels was better than any of the cast in this film which says to me that although there alot of decent acting here, no one was brilliant. Maybe Daisey and Peter Mayhew were strongest, then Han and John Boyega in that order.