I wouldn't say it's overrated cuz it was sick as fukk for it's time, it just aged like shytthe 100% unquestionable answer to this thread
is GOLDENEYE
Halo
Call of Duty
Basically 90% of the modern FPS franchises that get so much attention
Most FPS games are too repetitive and linear to be any good.
You all are just listing games you don't like.
bioshock 1