The narrative here (in the arcadium) is:This is a false dichotomy because it's not an either or choice. You can both have Game Pass and buy games and look at the value of what Game Pass gives you and feel like you got your money's worth as well as feel like the games you bought were worth it.
I'll be the first to say monthly rack rate for Game Pass is not worth the price of admission. But getting 3 years of Xbox Live Gold at Sams's or Costco or Newegg when on sale there and converting it for $1 to 3 years of Game Pass Unlimited is absolutely worth it because it's not hard to get 3 years for $50 per year.
Again internet tribalism tries to turn everything into an either or choice when in reality it usually isn't. You don't have to be an Xbot to sub to Game Pass and get value out of it. Nor do you have to be an Xbox to see the value in subscription services.
From Sony Stans: "Xbots are starving. They only have gamepass and no exclusives".
From Xbots: "Sony is starving, they only have 2 exclusives a year and gamepass has hundreds of games keeping us fed".
I'm not saying it's either or (I've said why the value of gamepass isn't there for me), I'm responding to the back and forth on here about how much better xbox is over playstation because of gamepass.
I agree that the retail cost of gamepass is not worth it for me. I currently have it because of the same loop holes a lot of people took advantage of. Once those are closed I'm not re-upping my sub.