I’m not sure Smith playing Neo works. Neo was a great role for Reeves because of the muted personality Neo has. Smith has too much personality for that role. Smith works best in roles his charm and charisma can shine through. Also without Fishburne as Morpheus the Matrix is trash.
I was going to post the exact same thought in re: Keanu. I also think that Reeves brings a certain level of vulnerability that Smith wouldn't be able to muster. Like, in both Speed and the Matrix, Reeves acts as if he's almost overwhelmed by the chaos that's going on around him, yet never fully goes over the line into losing it (save for the breakdown in Speed after his partner is blown up). While Smith can show vulnerability, I think he's too confident, too self-conscious to tow that line. Like in Enemy of the State; there was never a moment where I felt he wasn't in command of the situation.
Blazing saddles/BTTF 3....but yea will was an idiot for that one...think part of the reason was soundtrack money...he wasnt going to make a song for matrix.
IMO, Will's fatal flaw as an actor is his reluctance to take chances or relinquish control cf. Django Unchained.
This is neither here nor there, but I remember a story about some woman who was on her last legs, dying of cancer, so this one adult Make-A-Wish foundation asked her what she wanted before she died. She said she wanted to meet Will Smith, her favorite celebrity. She didn't get to
meet Will, but he did take the time to send her a personalized videotape of the making of Wild Wild West. On one level, it's nice that he took the time to make the tape; on the other hand, what a
terrible final gift.