This argument is laughable. You mean to tell me that Rose has been in the league for less time, has less playoff appearances, and has been injured for 2 straight years and STILL has more high scoring playoff games than CP3? Not only that, but he's lead his team to the best record in the league and marched into the conference finals, which CP3 hasn't been able to do with even more help? You mean to tell me that CP3's passive "pure point guard" play has not translated to great playoff success just like the many overrated "pure point guards" before him?
Athletic, multi-dimensional point guard play makes champions. Leave that "pure point" stuff for the role players.