Does Beyoncés overall greatness make people forget about her great singing capability??

[Harry B]

Alicia Keys 1st two albums received just as much, if not more critical acclaim, than Beyonce's last two albums, and that's her and Kerry Brothers competing against the entire Beyhive Tent Camp

Alicia Keys also isn't signed directly to the largest tour company in the world, so comparing tours isn't a fair argument

No they didn't not even close, googles your friend breh. Beyoncé is not signed to Live Nation either, both of them have had their tours arranged by Live Nation, what are you talking about?

Are you really in here saying that the reason Beyonces venues are 5 times bigger is due to Lige Nation arranging her tour .
Can they do this for 50 cent too?

 

[tuckgod]

Aaliyah ..... wasn't much of a talent. she was moreso a novelty act.

negged.

 

[Standing on business]

Alicia Keys 1st two albums received just as much, if not more critical acclaim, than Beyonce's last two albums, and that's her and Kerry Brothers competing against the entire Beyhive Tent Camp

Alicia Keys also isn't signed directly to the largest tour company in the world, so comparing tours isn't a fair argument

Why can't we compare tours
if the demand is there the tickets will sell. Alcicia can sign to that same tour company and still wouldn't be able to sell out arenas. Alicia had never been as big as Beyoncé is right now breh

 

[Homeboy Runny-Ray]

negged.

didn't know you were into the negging foolery. you looking funny in the light.

I liked Aaliyah but she was a manufactured singer. she shouldn't have been mentioned in this & the other thread.

the longer you keep letting your childhood nostalgia blind you, the longer youre gonna keep looking foolish.

 

[tuckgod]

Why can't we compare tours
if the demand is there the tickets will sell. Alcicia can sign to that same tour company and still wouldn't be able to sell out arenas. Alicia had never been as big as Beyoncé is right now breh

The demand is there solely because Beyonce has been reinvented into this Queen of the Universe type character, when in all actuality, if her team wasn't directly involved in sabotaging the careers off all her potential competition, to the point that now she's the ONLY BLACK AMERICAN FEMALE who's able to hold down a successful recording career, her career would most likely be faltering right now

Of course she's going to seem like a Goddess to these dizzy broads out here today, they have no other alternative to turn to besides Rihanna or some white broad

There is nothing special about Beyonce outside of the work of the team behind her over the years to create and sustain her image

There's chicks who can sing circles around her
Dance her off the stage
and
Look better than her

But you'll never hear about them, or if you do, they'll never be surrounded by the army of talent that Beyonce has access to, so they'll always seem inferior to her talent and image wise

 

[MooseMouthMthafuga]

its not about who you prefer to listen to. i'll put an Aaliyah record on before beyonce too. but in reality, I know I'm really just doing it for r.kelly or missy & timbaland.

Aaliyah was brought up in here as some sort of barrier or better option, when in reality, she wasn't much of a talent. she was moreso a novelty act.

that perspective is needed.

no theyre not BOTH robots. Aaliyah was but beyonce isn't. beyonce can actually sing, she writes at least some of the stuff she takes credit for and shes a great performer.

Technically, Bey's a much better singer , but her music radiates "plastic" more than any major artist I've ever seen.Like I said before, "technically"/ "by the book", she's probably a better singer than Teena Marie, but we all know she can't rock a mic like Teena.The proverbial "it"......Bey just don't have "it" to me.She's lucky to dominate such a watered down era.Her marketing/promotion team deserves an Oscar.They're god level over there

She's just a more efficient, updated model robot turbo 3000.....sonically roboticized, TV Dinner music.The evolution of plastic.


They'll roll another one off the assembly line to supplant her soon

 

[tuckgod]

didn't know you were into the negging foolery. you looking funny in the light.

I liked Aaliyah but she was a manufactured singer. she shouldn't have been mentioned in this & the other thread.

the longer you keep letting your childhood nostalgia blind you, the longer youre gonna keep looking foolish.

You must have me confused with another poster breh

Either way, to address this post

Aaliyah wasn't the greatest singer, I wouldn't even put her over Beyonce, but she was super talented all around

I also agree that mentioning her (or Beyonce) in a thread comparing them to a super talent like A. Keys is disrespectful

But, I negged you because your comment was also very disrespectful

Nothing more

 

[tuckgod]

Technically, Bey's a much better singer , but her music radiates "plastic" more than any major artist I've ever seen.Like I said before, "technically"/ "by the book", she's probably a better singer than Teena Marie, but we all know she can't rock a mic like Teena.The proverbial "it"......Bey just don't have "it" to me.She's lucky to dominate such a watered down era.Her marketing/promotion team deserves an Oscar.They're god level over there

She's just a more efficient, updated model robot turbo 3000.....sonically roboticized, TV Dinner music.The evolution of plastic.


They'll roll another one off the assembly line to supplant her soon

This.

All this

You hit it the nail on the head, breh

Some folks won't feel it because they've only been exposed to plastic music and don't even realize it

 

[Standing on business]

People saying B doesn't have "IT"

A successful 20 year music career says otherwise

 

[tuckgod]

People saying B doesn't have "IT"

A successful 20 year music career says otherwise

A successful 20 year music career means she:

Stepped on the right toes

Kissed the right asses

Said what she was told to say

Performed at the events she was told to

Shunned the artists/writers/producers/award shows/radio stations she was told to

Supported the artists/writers/producers/award shows/radio stations she was told to

Wore what she was told to wear, by whatever designer she was told to support

While always smiling, and taking whatever bullshyt they threw her way, unless of course, her image called for a little innocent, controlled rebellion from time to time

Bravo to her for being the best company woman the music recording industry has seen in the last 20 years though

However, none of that shyt does anything for me, or my ears, so I could give two shyts

Some of y'all might only know Queen Bey, but I remember vividly the cute little light skinned girl, with the struggle runs on "No, No, No"

And I've never really been that impressed

 

[volk]

this video shuts down all that "beyonce cant sing" shyt..

start at around 5:30 and just watch a few minutes..bytch voice like a jazz trumpetier. I fukks with it.

I like Beyonce, but these don't really sound that good to me. Her voice is kind of grating.

 

[OG Talk]

She's not an elite vocalist...

No shame in that because she's a great entertainer.. Some great singers don't have half of her charisma and ability to perform..

You cant have it all

 

[tuckgod]

Who's saying she can't sing better than Aaliyah and Mary J

People love Aaliyah because she made great songs, timeless without even being considered timeless.

Beyonce can blow, but her voice isn't unique just a good church voice

 

[tuckgod]

this video shuts down all that "beyonce cant sing" shyt..

That's cool, she can't do this though



and she damn sure can't even think of doing this

 

[ridedolo]

That's cool, she can't do this though



and she damn sure can't even think of doing this

and they couldnt dream of doing this, whats your point. their talent doesnt take away the fact that bey is the best singer + dancer since mj. show me someone who can sing AND perform at her level, male or female.