I might have said this last week already so I apologize but the problem/criticism I have with the convos we're seeing is that they feel disingenuous. The people loudly yelling that "country music is black music" have no real intention of verifying if it's true, or exploring the genre, or doing anything to familiarize themselves with anything beyond blindly retweeting information they aren't even consuming. The entire crux of all of this basically boils down to "Beyonce is doing this and I will support it." Nothing else matters. I felt the same way about her last album, where we suddenly had a certain demographic of people yelling about house music being black music yet doing nothing to explore the genre or learn why so many house/electronic stans weren't even that impressed by her album. While it's great that people are being exposed to different sounds as artists move away from the same downtempo+trap drum sounds of the last 15 years, I'm not sure it's truly appreciated or sinking in beyond just "support Beyonce."
I'm reminded of when Solange dropped an album that sounded nothing like what anyone expected, and the reactions were largely negative because she doesn't have the clout or cult that her sister has. If you venture too far out of the box of what urban black music is supposed to sound like, you get killed unless you have the fanbase and record label machine to sustain. To me that says a lot of bad things about modern music listeners and how closed off people's ears are. I'm not sure there's ever been a time in America where people essentially listened to one genre of music like they do now. If rap fans listen to r&b today it's largely rap production and rap-like lyrics. Everything is so homogenized and I'm not sure where the exit is.