Tobey was a great high school Peter. But he never evolved.I think Andrew was better than Tobey - and that Tobey was average as fukk, merely carried by supporting actors when he was at his best.
Kid had more personality in that one back and forth with Stark than the other two did in entire films.
Which is what most people mistake about Peter. Peter doesn't remain that introvert geek from high school. He grows up and he's always got a bad bytch. Being spider man changes him.
That's what raimis films got wrong. Well that and spider man being a fukking mute.
Andrew was a little too cool for high school but he was great for what Peter becomes and he was a good spider man. I still say he could have been perfect depending on how the next films shook out. Asm2 suffered from iron man 2 syndrome of being a bridge film to set up a universe.