Best Star Trek Captain?

[hayesc0]

For the voyager fans I meant to ask am I the only one that wants to fukk seska.

 

[ORDER_66]

For the voyager fans I meant to ask am I the only one that wants to fukk seska.

Who???

 

[Devilinurear]

which 2nd in command would make the best captain?

Riker

 

[Devilinurear]

Who???

she was the cardi spy in the maque

 

[DLo]

Coming into the thread I was 70/30 for Picard over Sisko. But y'all got me reminiscing over DS9 and how Sisko had no chill .

I need to go back and rewatch Voyager. I made it about 2 seasons and gave up.

Star Trek fans on the Coli... Y'all never fail me

 

[Pesci]

Who???

 

[Pesci]

Coming into the thread I was 70/30 for Picard over Sisko. But y'all got me reminiscing over DS9 and how Sisko had no chill .

I need to go back and rewatch Voyager. I made it about 2 seasons and gave up.

Star Trek fans on the Coli... Y'all never fail me

voyager was my first trek, really. so take this from an original fan.

i did a rewatch about two years ago. it's worth it to look up reviews for the episodes, because a lot of them are bad.

there's a big backstory about the writing for voyager, but the tldr is that certain writers wrote some really terrible episodes. i think brannon braga is probably the worst.

 

[hayesc0]

Who???

 

[Canada Goose]

Who???

she was one of the biggest villains from the first two seasons of Yoyager.

 

[Deltron]

Harry Kim might be the worst of the main crew characters on any of the shows. He is basically the same person at the end of Voyager as he was at the beginning (still an ensign too )

Voyager was my first Star Trek series, and IMO it holds up the worst between itself, TNG, and DS9. There are too many crappy episodes.

the only character trait/arc he achieved was being best friends with Tom fukking Paris...and simping a hologram, borg, and an alien race of women who wanted to steal his genetics.

Well I guess dying and being replaced by a duplicate copy is something too


Even fukking Nelix had more arcs. Even Naomi Wyleman did!

 

[mr x]

the only character trait/arc he achieved was being best friends with Tom fukking Paris...and simping a hologram, borg, and an alien race of women who wanted to steal his genetics.

Well I guess dying and being replaced by a duplicate copy is something too


Even fukking Nelix had more arcs. Even Naomi Wyleman did!

but he had control of the bridge on the night shift.
that's good resume building for when they got home

 

[DLo]

voyager was my first trek, really. so take this from an original fan.

i did a rewatch about two years ago. it's worth it to look up reviews for the episodes, because a lot of them are bad.

there's a big backstory about the writing for voyager, but the tldr is that certain writers wrote some really terrible episodes. i think brannon braga is probably the worst.

Can you do that and keep up with the story?

 

[ORDER_66]

IDK thats why I asked I dont remember every errant character on voyager.... DS9 on the other hand was clearly the superior show...

 

[Pesci]

Can you do that and keep up with the story?

Yeah you can. Thinking back, there are only a few real stinkers that I remember. It went 7 season so we're talking probably like 140 episodes at least.

 

[hayesc0]

IDK thats why I asked I dont remember every errant character on voyager.... DS9 on the other hand was clearly the superior show...

Yeah she died early in the series and made a few appearances later on once in a holodeck episode and time travel episode.