Am I A Hater For Rolling My Eyes At These Zelda Reviews?

[Greenhornet]

might as well shut this sub forum down

same people that complain about everything are mad at the GOAT adventure game
for giving you your own open world choices, and a new system where you can combine and craft anything

how you gonna say a game with 100s of hours of gameplay and 1000s of options is less than a 7/10 (nearly failing grade)
but then call 20 hour, linear, cut scene quicktime button prompt, part 7 of a similar game is classic?

nikkas staying being hypocrites on this site and contradicting themselves

 

[Gizmo_Duck]

also funny how the same people that complain about “movie games” are no where to be found in the zelda thread

 

[winb83]

also funny how the same people that complain about “movie games” are no where to be found in the zelda thread

There's a sizable chunk of the 18-34 or whatever male gamer demographic that have zero interest in Nintendo and any games they make.

 

[Khalil's_Black_Excellence]

might as well shut this sub forum down

same people that complain about everything are mad at the GOAT adventure game
for giving you your own open world choices, and a new system where you can combine and craft anything

how you gonna say a game with 100s of hours of gameplay and 1000s of options is less than a 7/10 (nearly failing grade)
but then call 20 hour, linear, cut scene quicktime button prompt, part 7 of a similar game is classic?

nikkas staying being hypocrites on this site and contradicting themselves

Ummm...who said it was under a 7/10 tho? I think even alleged "haters" have it at an 8. It's just some of the hype is to an absurd level tho and folks will act as if there nothing to critique on it.

 

[Fctftl]

they need to rename this shyt The Legend of Zelda: Tears of the Gamers with all the crying over the acclaim its getting.

I was on the Forespoken reddit today in anticipation for the DLC and they were making threads crying about the Zelda reviews too

 

[Greenhornet]

Ummm...who said it was under a 7/10 tho? I think even alleged "haters" have it at an 8. It's just some of the hype is to an absurd level tho and folks will act as if there nothing to critique on it.

simply read back through the last 10 pages in this thread to see people rating it 7/10 or under

 

[Deafheaven]

simply read back through the last 10 pages in this thread to see people rating it 7/10 or under

I got it at like a 8

 

[O³ (O cubed)]

To the OP, no, you're not wrong. There's a blind spot that reviewers and fans have got for Nintendo.

If this game was on Xbox it would be criticised to the moon.

People were complaining about Halo, Gears and Forza yet Zelda, Mario (Kart, Tennis, platform game) and Pokémon have been recycled over and over. Heck the last one was buggy as fukk and still did over 10m.

I'm not saying that the game is bad, but stick the game on another platform and remove the Zelda name. I don't see that it would get the same score.

 

[Diunx]

Word how many hours you put into TOTK btw?

30 something so far.

 

[Insensitive]

I'm not even trying to hate but I feel like the ratings this shyt is getting are crazy.

I'm playing Ragnarok right now, it's a phenomenal piece of software that I would say is only
rivaled by like Gears 5 and The Last Of Us 2.
How in the fukk don't these other titles have these "Greatest game of all time" scores like the two most
recent Zelda titles have gotten ?

 

[Deafheaven]

I'm not even trying to hate but I feel like the ratings this shyt is getting are crazy.

I'm playing Ragnarok right now, it's a phenomenal piece of software that I would say is only
rivaled by like Gears 5 and The Last Of Us 2.
How in the fukk don't these other titles have these "Greatest game of all time" scores like the two most
recent Zelda titles have gotten ?

IDK

its a cool lil game but I feel its made for nikkas who like to waste time or love to experiment to do menial things. It also seems like you can break the game easily since you can just chomp on endless food how does one die in this

I'm not a big fan of either so I'm having really sporadic sessions with it.

 

[Gizmo_Duck]

I'm not even trying to hate but I feel like the ratings this shyt is getting are crazy.

I'm playing Ragnarok right now, it's a phenomenal piece of software that I would say is only
rivaled by like Gears 5 and The Last Of Us 2.
How in the fukk don't these other titles have these "Greatest game of all time" scores like the two most
recent Zelda titles have gotten ?

God of War Ragnarok is literally two points below Tears of The Kingdom

 

[Lambent55]

I can kind of see where the OP coming from. I've been seeing some streamers not really feeling this game, one of them being CohhCarnage who dropped it. They didn't say it was bad, just that they're not feeling it.

 

[5n0man]

Debatable.

I love elden ring, but theres much more to do in ToTK open world than just kill shyt also

BOTW had awful combat and TOTK is the same, so I'd give it to elden ring personally.

 

[gtj1982]

Haven’t played it so I can’t say this one or overrated but I could never get into Zelda games growing up. They just boring to me. I can say Zelda gets a pass for shoot other games her heart for. Also I side eye when reviewers reference feeling like a kid again.