It's not that people think he's good.....he actually IS fairly good and I've never taken that away from him. He rarely (if ever) botches and he speaks fairly confidently and intelligently
The problem is, he's just not that exciting or charismatic on the mic. He gets his point across mind you, and I wouldn't go as far as to say he's "boring" (that would be guys like Bret and Lance Storm, who sometimes did verge on that "boring" sound just by the tone of their voice, even though Bret could sound convincingly angry/confident when he needed to)....but at the same time, he's no Dwayne......he's no Austin......he's no Hogan.....he's no HBK....he's no Jericho.
He doesn't have that delivery that indicates that he's an interesting/exciting character. At best, he just sounds like your average angry white man. Even Cena stands out more than he does in that regard, as wack as a lot of his actual promos are
Yet his stans would have you think that he's one of the GOATs on the mic
![rudy :rudy: :rudy:](https://www.thecoli.com/styles/default/xenforo/smilies/rudy2.png)
......when he's nowhere near that
That's the problem.....dude is overrated on the mic