1. i have no problem with having convos and don't have a problem with the overall question of the thread (why is ryse getting bad scores when it does such and such good?)...the reason it comes off as you having a problem is cause no matter what anyone says, you continue to try to make another game look better by trying to make another game look bad instead of just stating your reasons why you think the bad rated game is getting an unfair rating...using a game to compare as an example is cool, but trying to make it seem like the game you're comparing it to shouldn't be considered good cause of the very reasons the bad game is getting called bad is not cool...
2. you don't see how that's bashing uncharted?...how all the shyt you're saying ryse is getting shytted on for that uncharted does isn't fair and how either ryse should be given a pass or uncharted should be getting shytted on for those too isnt bashing?...how you constantly saying uncharted gets praise only for being cinematic and presentation isn't bashing?....like the other shyt didn't have anything to do with praise...
3 & 5. i'll take your word for it since I haven't played it yet...just find it odd that everyone else compares it to hack/slash games, but you compare to a shooter...but again: don't try to play that bullshyt 'I played it, you didn't' card....cause that would mean a lot of the shyt a lot of yall talk shouldn't be said/taken seriously....especially when yall haven't played games that haven't come out but yet form such deep & strong thoughts/opinions on them...not once have I bashed ryse and I wont unless I play it and it gives me a reason to bash it...
6. no they wouldn't be reviewed differently...i understand why the scores are based on a lot of shyt i dont care about like frame rates, visual output, etc....what i'm saying is fun is the only thing that should matter to us, the gamers....what a game gets scored by others shouldn't matter to you if you find the game fun...
7. lol and you believe that shyt?...those arent fans of the game cause a fan of the series isnt gonna say i'm only a fan cause it looks good since it's more to uncharted than that...they probably saying that shyt to look 'unbiased'...the same shyt happens when talking about music artists: 'repeat some universal praise', but then proceed to bash the artist about everything; but say at the end 'i'm a fan though'......anyway, if uncharted was only about production/graphics, it wouldn't be getting praised like it does...cause a lot of games look good nowadays, but don't get the praise of uncharted...in fact you have to purposely make a 'bad looking' game nowadays...also, I just find it funny that you believe the people's opinions that match yours, but doubt the ones that don't...
8. (look at answer 2)...to add to it: i'm not repeating what I've read, i'm going off what someone whose played the game said that I've talked with...the reason I say i think that part has to do with Kinect is cause it continues even if you get it wrong....it seems like executions were gonna be automatic, but that it was changed to qtes when they decided to make the switch to a non Kinect game...
...I haven't said you made shyt up, i'm repeating shyt from someone I've talked with that has played the game and what I've seen of the game (vids, trailers, not reviews)....just cause I and others don't agree with you doesn't mean we think you lying...that's another example of how you keep showing you have a problem with the opinion the game might just not be fun....cause you're really trying to say your opinion is right and others is wrong....we're stating opinions, not facts...
have you played both? Probably not.
there is no need to lie to get your point across. You have talked to no one that told you the executions feel like kinect. That is something you read about the game from someone who had not played the game 6 months before it came out 
