Who is the 5th Best QB in the NFL?

[BucciMane]

it's mahomes ,lamar, burrow, then a gap. Then you have the likes of allen, daniels, stroud etc. Allen winning MVP this year is not based on merit but on affirmative action. He has the easiet division in football with 4-5 easy wins every year and a media desperate to anoint him king for spamming 1 yard tush push rushing touchdowns

.

I’ve seen a lot of absolutely horrible posters over the years, but you may be, objectively, the absolutely dumbest I’ve seen in a long time. Every thread and every post gives me near brain damage. As someone said about Malc before, you are pretty much digital Aids.

 

[FLORIDA BOI]

Goff

 

[Copy Ninja]

Lets keep it a buck...if he looked the part you wouldnt be saying this. If a Stafford or Herbert had his numbers and record with teams that were ass before they arrived its a different discussion.

What does the bolded even mean? Goff was the #1 overall pick. He does look the part that's why he was picked that high

 

[murksiderock]

What does the bolded even mean? Goff was the #1 overall pick. He does look the part that's why he was picked that high

You know what he means. He doesn't have the arm Stafford has, and while he's tall he doesn't have Matt's frame either, he isn't as thick between the shoulders...

You combine that with Matt's quick processing and delivery, his toughness, it's not a secret that NFL people prefer Stafford's characteristics...

I prefer quarterbacks who are elite but also win. I don't really care about the play style if they are elevators of talent and winners...

 

[Blessings]

Lets keep it a buck...if he looked the part you wouldnt be saying this. If a Stafford or Herbert had his numbers and record with teams that were ass before they arrived its a different discussion.

If???

When has he looked the part?

 

[FTBS]

If???

When has he looked the part?

I dont understand what you are saying. It seems like you arent understanding what I am saying either. See @murksiderock 's post above.

 

[VegetasHairline]

.

I’ve seen a lot of absolutely horrible posters over the years, but you may be, objectively, the absolutely dumbest I’ve seen in a long time. Every thread and every post gives me near brain damage. As someone said about Malc before, you are pretty much digital Aids.

He's a Chat GPT bot with a holier than thou attitude.

 

[FTBS]

You know what he means. He doesn't have the arm Stafford has, and while he's tall he doesn't have Matt's frame either, he isn't as thick between the shoulders...

You combine that with Matt's quick processing and delivery, his toughness, it's not a secret that NFL people prefer Stafford's characteristics...

I prefer quarterbacks who are elite but also win. I don't really care about the play style if they are elevators of talent and winners...

Agree with everything but this quick processing shyt. Dude led the league in picks his first year in LA and tried to throw the season away vs SF and threw multiple picks in the SB. I watched many a game with the Lions where superior processing woulda been beneficial.

 

[OscarAcosta]

.

I’ve seen a lot of absolutely horrible posters over the years, but you may be, objectively, the absolutely dumbest I’ve seen in a long time. Every thread and every post gives me near brain damage. As someone said about Malc before, you are pretty much digital Aids.

They are the posts of someone who uses a head wand to type. I feel myself getting dumber with every word I read - he’s painful, so fukking painful.

 

[murksiderock]

Agree with everything but this quick processing shyt. Dude led the league in picks his first year in LA and tried to throw the season away vs SF and threw multiple picks in the SB. I watched many a game with the Lions where superior processing woulda been beneficial.

I agree, I don't think he's some elite processor either but people have said he's a better processor for McVay's system, so whatever

 

[KidJSoul]

What big games has he won? I don't remember em so there can't be many

They've made the same number of playoff appearances and one of em has yet to even win a single playoff game. Hope that changes for your guy this year, though

Herbert has some of the most game winning drives since he's entered the league

2021 against the Raiders was going to be a big game but his coach sabotaged him

In 2022 he beat the dolphins (playoff team) Sunday night to get his team in the playoffs

And this year he beat the Bengals and Broncos in pivotal prime time games to get them into the playoffs (and also prevent Cincy from making it).

Burrow's biggest playoff win of his career was a game where Mahomes just choked.

 

[Saysumthinfunnymike]

This is what "top 5 Herbert" gets you?

Lol...Golden Cac

 

[murksiderock]

This is what "top 5 Herbert" gets you?

Lol...Golden Cac

Just threw pick #4 Herbert was never a Top 5 guy but got the second most votes in this thread...

"Justin Herbert is Just A Guy" ...

 

[DraymondT]

Been told yall nikkas Jayden top 5

Playoff debut on the road against one of the most prolific defensive minds of this generation who known for shyttin on young QBs too. Looked like he was up against a vet

Jayden a rookie and already the best QB in NFC. Don't even know how you argue it at this point

 

[FabTrey]

Been told yall nikkas Jayden top 5

Playoff debut on the road against one of the most prolific defensive minds of this generation who known for shyttin on young QBs too. Looked like he was up against a vet

Jayden a rookie and already the best QB in NFC. Don't even know how you argue it at this point

Stroud played like he could be a future top 5 player last year, but his play dropped off significantly in year 2. I like what i'm seeing from Daniels, but i'm not crowning a rookie in year 1.