Brehs, I had to up this thread. I've just finished reading the books over the last couple of months. I read them when they were originally released, but this was the first time back-to-back-to-back-etc... I noticed @LegendNas post about how Deathy Hallows was received, & I found the same thing. My original feeling back in '07 was that it was a bit of a letdown & a disappointing way to finish a great series, but reading that shyt again, I couldn't have been more wrong. I think a large part of it was that 'Nineteen Years Later' really left me with a bad taste in my mouth. I know Rowling said she had that chapter written from day one, but I think it would've been better without it, & would've left their futures to be open to personal interpretations - just my preference for novels in general.
But brehs, that series had an impression on me more so than any other series I've read. I'm not ashamed to admit that the latter books gave me a lump in my throat on a few occasions! The chapter in Order of the Phoenix when Dumbledore finally reveals the truth about the prophecy was powerful as hell (although Harry's anger in this book did go over the top for me). The chapter ending with Dumbledore, so strong & infallible to this point, shedding a tear about the pressure Harry has had to live with was
Dumbledore is one of the GOAT characters period. Mr Perfect suddenly turned on his head in the final book, revealing his shady, secretive side was brilliant. He got to me twice in Half-Blood Prince, seeing him tortured by that potion in the cave, & then when Harry is helping him escape & he says
I'm not worried, Harry, because I am with you... Goddamn it J.K.
Snape is an obvious other one; what a deep character. Seeing him get shytted on throughout his life & meeting such a grisly end made you feel compassion for such a previously loathsome man.
Hermione, though, what a woman
Has there ever been a more loyal girl? I don't have a problem with Harry ending up with Ginny, but the whole thing could've been handled better IMO. Leaving it until the end of
#6 & then breaking it off without us even reading much about them being together didn't sit right with me - I mean, this is the hero's girl! I still haven't seen the final two films, so hearing about some weird dance between Harry & Hermione seems pretty alien to me, I'll have to check that out. Ginny has balls, though. shyt cracked me up when Cho offered to show Harry Ravenclaw's diadem & Ginny was basically like: "bytch, sit your ass back down. Luna can go
"
How anyone can like Ron over Hermione is a joke. One of the things that struck me reading the series again was just how much Ron is pretty unlikable; all the way, in fact, until he returns in the Forest of Dean (BTW how amazing is the locket's way of trying to dissuade Ron from destroying it?!). I think this is where the movies had altered my thinking - Ron being such a entertaining clown in most of them made me forget how much of a dikk he regularly was in the books. I didn't really like Neville until the last couple of books, but obviously, his change from useless kid to fearless leader is meant to change your mind about him.
Seeing Neville's parents in St Mungo's was powerful. There were a bunch of those sad moments in Deathly Hallows. Fred seeing George wounded when they removed Harry from the Dursleys is one; they'd been pretty one-dimensional up until that point, & obviously they start cracking jokes after George wakes up, but for a moment you see Fred's real horror at his twin being hurt
Harry interacting with his parents, specifically his mother, is a tough read, too. The Mirror of Erised - although that's a little too early to have formed much of a connection with his character - starts it off. But mainly Harry reading her torn letter in Sirius's bedroom & him tracing the words Lily had once actually wrote, visiting their graves in Godric's Hollow after all that time, & finally him bringing back the four with the Resurrection Stone as he's about to face his death... Rowling was fukking ruthless killing Lupin & Tonks right after Teddy being born, leaving him as another orphan. Lupin (the best & most tragic of the Marauders) saying he's sorry he'll never get to know his own son, shyt hit me hard
Speaking of Godric's Hollow, the Bathilda Bagshot chapter is scary as hell. Maybe scary is the wrong word, but the whole silent, eerie feel in the build-up, the Parseltongue freaking out Hermione but seeming normal to Harry, to Nagini emerging from a dead woman's fukking enchanted corpse & Voldemort racing to the scene was making my damn hands tremble while reading
Same happened in the Malfoy Manor chapter, which was amazing. Poor Dobby. If you think about it, the last 200 pages happen in one continuous stretch: from waking up at Shell Cottage to heading to Gringotts, all the way until the book ends is one fukking unbelievable 24 hours! I'm going to read that section again, while knowing how things unfold still fresh in my mind.
Brehs, I could talk about the series for days, but seeing as how old the thread is, I don't know whether anyone is still interested. That was without even mentioning much of the symbolism or Lord Voldemort & the Death Eaters...