What are you talking about?
Reasonable Doubt is a classic record but it brought nothing new (apart from Jay himself) to the game. Production was helmed largely by established producers doing what they do best. Rap content was Mafioso which everyone in NY was doing. Rap style was similar to Nas.
Yea and Jay gets dinged for that. It's that lack of originality that's kept him from ever having an album of the year. To a degree everybody bites... Nas bit Rae and Biggie, Rae bit Kool G Rap, Kool G Rap bit the mafia etc. etc. But none of em bit to the extent this clown Troy Ave does.
There's plenty of artists that haven't done anything new. Rolling Stones were simply a blues band.
If thats all you think Rolling Stones are, you are not very familiar with their catalog. There are elements of blues, sure, but they are not a blatant BB King ripoff
How many rappers in the game have just taken Wayne's autotune warble phase as a fulltime career?
Wayne took his autotune warble from someone else. And all of those rappers are garbage too.
50 Cent himself was hardly an original artist.
Thats debatable. U can see where he drew things from, but again, he took old things and combined them in a new way, and brought an energy/element that was clearly missing from the game.
With Troy - it just sounds too much like 50 Cent though. The album was decent. It's not trash. It's not completely redundant of style or skill..
I havent heard the whole album, but the "POTD" biting is too fukking blatant. If u want to give him props for being a good copycat cool, but biting another rappers style verbatim doesn't require any style or skill. Troy Ave is def not the avenue for NY's comeback, or even music worth listening to to be honest.