first uncharted game I've ever played. thought it was great but not mind blowing like some people here. maybe it's cause you guys played the whole series and were more invested in the characters. I give it a solid 9. felt like the game play got repetitive after a while. jump, climb, rope. jump, climb rope. solve a puzzle. jump, climb, rope.
it was great but some chapters felt like a chore. don't see this having any replay value for me. the detail and fluidity of the game was amazing though. I think there was maybe one hiccup in the framerate the whole time I played. for how much shyt was going on that's impressive. the story was great. even if the dialogue in the final fight scene was kinda cheesy.
as far as gameplay goes, I still feel dying light holds the crown for ps4 titles. easily.