Trade 3 Firsts and a 3rd for a 4th Brehs - Official 2023 San Francisco 49ers Season Thread!!!

[yseJ]

I agree that Shanny has his issues but so did Andy Reid. I'd argue that Andy Reid is still the same coach he always was, very good coach but he has Michael Jordan at quarterback.

We don't have that luxury. We have Purdy who actually looked really good in high pressure situations. But to beat Kansas City, it's the same as the Patriots were. You have to play a perfect game.

Do I think Shanny was perfect? Hell no... I thought his playcalling was very suspect for a long stretch of the game. But the two biggest plays of the game were the muffed punt which Shanny can't do anything about and the block PAT which Shanny can't do anything about.

If y'all were around in the 90s, this is what it was like watching the Bulls. You can't let Michael Jordan hang around. We let Michael Jordan hang around.

Our best chance to win a Super Bowl with Shanny is probably having an AFC team upset Mahomes first...

this isnt about andy or even kyle per se though...I dont think Niner fans will care much if kyle goes elsewhere and wins a ring... the question is can the Niners win a ring with this team and Kyle coaching it

the core of this team doesnt have a lot of time left. we're looking at a big rebuild coming up in a couple of years or maybe even in one year

 

[Saysumthinfunnymike]

this isnt about andy or even kyle per se though...I dont think Niner fans will care much if kyle goes elsewhere and wins a ring... the question is can the Niners win a ring with this team and Kyle coaching it

They can because as I've laid out. The roster is going to be great again next year and the NFC isn't scary at all. That's what I've been saying. @Jmare007 can say he's not going to be invested but if we are in the playoffs competing again I find it hard to believe y'all won't be up in these threads lol

 

[EzekelRAGE]

 

[Saysumthinfunnymike]

We've had this discussion like 3 times this season alone, no reason to go down the same path. All I'll say is that there more options than "contend with Kyle or go back to useless HCs"

And it's a moot argument anyway, Kyle ain't leaving before his current deal expires in like 4 more years.

Yes, I know you think the answer is "find another head coach" but I don't think that's the answer and like you said, he's not leaving anyway so this is what it is.
Shanny alone as a coach with a nice roster is levels above the 9 year stretch of Erickson to Tomsula.

 

[Saysumthinfunnymike]

This graphic is trash. Purdy played well and the reasons they lost...there's about ten reasons and none of them even have anything to do with Purdy.

Plus, we all hated Jimmy G. Nobody ever took Jimmy G seriously after the first season except a couple guys who were late to the party. We wanted Jimmy G gone for years.

 

[yseJ]

this is stupid, we went from jimmy to purdy once, and it was a clear upgrade

the trey lance trade and inability to judge talent and develop raw talent should be under way more scrutiny

 

[EzekelRAGE]

 

[Saysumthinfunnymike]

Yeah.. I think Purdy is the first QB that most of the fan base has liked since.... Kaepernick in '12-'13 maybe

And none of us call Purdy elite, we just say he's been good..

 

[Jmare007]

They can because as I've laid out. The roster is going to be great again next year and the NFC isn't scary at all. That's what I've been saying. @Jmare007 can say he's not going to be invested but if we are in the playoffs competing again I find it hard to believe y'all won't be up in these threads lol

I'll be in the threads as I always have been.

 

[EzekelRAGE]

And none of us call Purdy elite, we just say he's been good..

People try to say Purdy ain’t Elite

But those the type playS elite QBs makes

And Purdy has made a lot of them

If it looks like a duck
Walk like a duck
Quacks like a duck

At some point y’all niccas gotta identify it as a duck

 

[Bryan Danielson]

And technically I still didn’t say he was….

But Spags and the defensive staff themself said dude looked like and reminded them of Brees last night




Who are you and me to question Spaggs?

 

[Busby]

Me currently:

 

[feelosofer]

Special teams coach needs to be fired.

Also Kyle didn't coach the team on the new overtime rules did he.

Wild.

 

[Dr. Narcisse]

No QB deserves the Kaep treatment.

Like with Lamar, Roman didnt evolve.
Then you promote Tomsula and Chryst and run a worst version of the offense.
Chip Kelly's offense was figured out his 2nd go round as a HC with less talent on the 49ers.

Bad business

It will be interesting to see what happens with Brocks extension after next season. This team is old, top heavy and plays 20 games every damn year.

Kyle isn't going anywhere. But I think they will think about long term contract with Brock just because once you do it, there is no going back.

Yea cause for all of Kyle's flaws its Brock who executes his offense the best. No guarantee whoever they bring in is scheming Deebo and Kittle open like that.

I watched every snap of CMC in Carolina. Even with his #s...He wasnt THIS. 49ers and Shanahan have a lot to do with this.

The nerve of them putting Darnold in their as a "key free agent"

I'll say it. They coulda kept Trey. Bring him to run power on those goalline short yardage plays.


Of course Kyle wanted to save Darnold's career instead.

 

[King Kreole]

Special teams coach needs to be fired.

Also Kyle didn't coach the team on the new overtime rules did he.

Wild.

I think the overtime rules thing is overblown. I yelled when we chose to receive, and I don't understand Kyle's reasoning for doing so, but it coaching the players to know the rules wouldn't have made any difference. Mecole Hardman caught the game winning TD and had no idea because he didn't know the rules either.