I'm not even gonna respond to all that, I'll pick the most interesting parts.
1. C4 didn't influence people the same way C2 or Dedication 2 did. It's not always about sales. BP3 sold a lot more than WTT but besides the two first singles, it didn't have any influence on pop culture, rap culture or anything. As for Wayne, he didn't rap about Balenciaga a broad did it. It wasn't really popping for men back then, just like people been rapping about Louboutin shoes for WOMEN until Pharell, Swizz and Kanye introduced people to the male version. People been rapping about LV for a whole, but there is a reason they call Kanye the LV Don.
2. I believe I said influence is not the same thing as starting something. If that was the case Illmatic and OB4CL didn't have any influence at all. Bringing things to the forefront, making things pop, being the source of peoples reference, no one knows how a few Philly broads pronounced crazy but the whole world know how Kanye did it that is influence in term he might've been influenced by some brother from Philly he saw on youtube.
3. The thing about big duos, just sparked all types of rumors, everyone from tip/Jeezy, Drake/Ross etc started talking about doing it after being inspired by Watch The Throne. That's not a major influence, cause it's been done and discussed before, but just bringing back all these discussion was imo worth mentioning.
Again bring shyt back, making shyt hot, creating TRENDS vs someone whispering something or just mentioning it and no one caring are two very different things IMO.
What type of influence did Pac had? he didn't do shyt no one hadn't done before him. But he did it 10 times better, he made it hot, he created trends, he brought shyt back, he did it on that over level, he made people all over the world care about these points he might've heard from his uncle, clothes he might've heard Rakim mention in a interview. You need to look up the words influence & impact , cause no one has claimed Jay or Kanye were the first to do anything.
Again...
I'm talking about influence sparked from originality or
within the culture...Which is part of the essense of hip hop..You are talking about
attention brought to pop culture or mainstream america...The way you dismiss the "hood chicks in Philly" on some "nobody cares about them" is part of the problem.. And part of the mentality that caused Blacks to lose jazz and rock and roll....
The most popular figures will always have a broader influence based simply off of their popularity.. So in that instance you are 100% right..But to call WTT the most influential project of the last 10 years just isn't true....
Culturally Trap or Die had a much bigger influence, although 45 year old soccer moms from Iowa probably don't know it existed...So it got less
attention...
Here is an example of how the popularity you speak about sparks
attention but not
influence...
1-Some street/pimp dudes in the Bay "dust their shoulder off" in the 70's (thousands of people are influenced)
2-Rappers like E-40, B-Legit and Short talk about "dustin their shoulder off" in raps in the late 80's and early 90's (hundreds of thousands are influenced because E-40 has a larger audience than the corner pimps)
3-Jay-Z makes a song called "Dirt off your Shoulder" in 2004 (millions of people experience attention because he has a larger audience than 40)
4-Obama does the "Dirt Off You Shoulder" in that North Carolina press conference (The whole world is now has attention because his audience is in the billions)
Now you can say that Obama made "brushing your shoulder off" popular..True.. But only if you come from a perspective of someone outside of the culture from which it actually came from...
At the end of that day the influence is diluted the further and further you get away from the original source (that pimp n!gga from Oakland) And of course nobody gives a damn about him because he's not rich and popular...
The fact that Jay is the most mainstream and popular rapper (Kanye is in that conversation to) gives everything he says or does attention OUTSIDE of the culture..And by the time these things get to the masses, we as a culture have already moved on to something else..
[ame="http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yM4xJsql20U"]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yM4xJsql20U[/ame]
Andre's little speech at the end explains exactly what I'm talking about...