Title windows for NE, DEN, PIT
Sustained success in the NFL, especially when compared to its major North American professional sports counterparts (NBA, NHL and MLB), is arduous to achieve.
The
Atlanta Falcons slid from the top seed in the NFC in 2012 to the basement of the NFC South in 2013. The
Washington Redskins went from being a middling squad to the playoffs in 2012, only to regress back to the bottom of the NFC East last season.
Windows don't close gently in the NFL. They often collapse.
In evaluating teams whose window could soon shut, we need to establish whose is currently open. For that, we turned to the top of our Future Power Rankings list, which will be unveiled Thursday on ESPN Insider.
There are many contributing factors to a team dropping in the standings from one season to the next: crippling injuries and difficult schedules (especially following a year with a favorable schedule) are among them. But for the purpose of this exercise, we're not going to predict or project injuries. They're unpredictable. (Case in point: A healthy
Andrew Luckkeeps the Colts among the Super Bowl contenders for the next 10-12 years. A major injury to Luck sends them spiraling toward a 6-10 season based on the talent around him.)
The bottom line for teams whose windows close after sustained success is that it almost always derives from two factors: a change (injury, free agency departure, etc.) in quarterback, or the exposure of mediocre talent surrounding a franchise quarterback. With that in mind, let's dig deeper on three candidates whose window
could close in the next three years.
New England Patriots
The skinny: Injuries terrorized the Patriots in 2013. Tight end
Rob Gronkowski, linebacker
Jerod Mayo, nose tackle
Vince Wilfork, right tackle
Sebastian Vollmer and linebacker
Brandon Spikes all finished the season on injured reserve. That's not even an all-encompassing list. And yet, the prevailing narrative as the Patriots marched on to their third straight AFC Championship Game was that with head coach Bill Belichick and quarterback
Tom Brady, they're always in the hunt.
There's often a desire -- it makes for great sports radio fodder -- to decipher just who is
most responsible for the Patriots' success during their unmatched run in the Belichick/Brady era. The truth is, both are among the very best to ever approach their craft. Both have played instrumental roles. But while the shelf life on Belichick's contributions extends seemingly until his desire to coach fades, Brady will be 37 when this season begins. Yes, he remains among the best quarterbacks in football -- I'd have no trouble calling him the best -- but just as team windows close quickly, players can similarly regress in just one season's time. Brett Favre was brilliant in throwing 33 touchdown passes and just seven interceptions (a career low for years in which he was a full-time player) during his penultimate season in 2009. The next year was far less kind, with Favre throwing 11 touchdown passes and 19 interceptions.
Would we count on Brady regressing in 2014? Hardly, he is as meticulous in his preparation as any player Belichick has coached. But it's fathomable that his play will slide at some point before he reaches 40.
And if it does, where does that leave the Patriots? The current quarterback situation includes
Ryan Mallett and second-round pick Jimmy Garoppolo, but neither has a legitimate NFL résumé.
The rest of the roster isn't weak, certainly not for the present. (It received a cumulative 79.25 grade from our experts contributing to the Future Power Rankings, sixth best among all teams.) But among the Patriots' younger building blocks, many aren't under contract past 2015 (cornerback
Darrelle Revis, 2014 with a 2015 team option that is unlikely to be used; safety
Devin McCourty, 2014; running backs
Shane Vereen and
Stevan Ridley, 2014; offensive tackle
Nate Solder, 2015). The point is, Brady and Belichick lift this roster. If one half of the powerful tag team isn't in the mix, there's reason for concern.
What could keep them in it: As stated, a Brady regression is far from a guarantee. He's under contract for four more seasons, and while there's little precedent for quarterbacks playing into their 40s, he's a rare player.
Moreover, while the sample size is small, we've seen the Patriots without Brady in 2008, and they won 11 games. Even if it was against a watered-down schedule, that's hard to do in the NFL. Belichick is the preeminent coach of his generation (perhaps of all time), and the organization is strong in all the foundational positions. (Their front office ranked seventh overall in our FPR, and the coaching staff ranked first.) Few teams adapt to change better than New England, and if Belichick stays in it for the long haul, the Patriots cannot be counted out.
Denver Broncos
The skinny: The argument as to why the Broncos' window will soon close profiles much of the same as the Patriots: What does life after
Peyton Manning look like? The team's aggressive offseason spending, led by signing cornerback
Aqib Talib, outside linebacker
DeMarcus Ware and safety
T.J. Ward, suggests a win-now mentality.
Manning had one of the finest seasons for any quarterback in NFL history in 2013, coasting to yet another MVP award. But unlike Brady, there were aspects to his game where his age did show. The accuracy was there, but his arm strength has clearly subsided since major neck surgeries during the 2011 season. If the residual effects continue to mount, Manning's play could regress. While we wouldn't count on it, Manning already has dealt with -- deflected, really -- questions about retirement for multiple seasons.
Beyond Manning, the Broncos have as much certainty at quarterback as the Patriots do past Brady: none.
Brock Osweiler was a second-round pick in 2012, but his pro track record is bare.
Demaryius Thomas,
Julius Thomas,
Von Miller,
Chris Harris and
Terrance Knighton are all among the young blue-chippers who will need new contracts before the end of 2015. While the team has already begun the process of tending to some of that business (Demaryius Thomas reportedly has been offered a new five-year deal), shrewd cap management will be needed. Those players are among the reasons why the Broncos' roster, outside of the quarterback, ranked third in our FPR.
What could keep them in it: John Elway, the Broncos' football czar, is still a relative newcomer to the front office scene, but he's already displayed a sharp eye for talent, especially on the free-agent level. (It's still too soon to evaluate his draft classes comprehensively.) Guard
Louis Vasquez, defensive end
Shaun Phillips and Knighton are among the wise pickups by Elway on the open market, contributing to the Broncos' front office ranking third in the NFL. We'd also contend that the talent surrounding Manning that is under contract for three or more seasons trumps that of Brady's (as our group FPR confirms). And, of course, Manning could keep up his pace of play beyond the three seasons for which he remains under contract.
Pittsburgh Steelers
The skinny: Underrated. That's how we'd describe quarterback
Ben Roethlisberger. But he's currently under contract through just 2015. How likely would it be for Big Ben to bolt on the open market? We'd guess it's extremely unlikely, but we can't ignore it.
And, unlike the two teams previously mentioned, the Steelers aren't coming off a playoff season. They nearly snuck into the playoffs last year, but they entered December at 5-8 before closing with three straight wins.
The cap-strapped Steelers were hardly active on the free-agent market this offseason, and while they alleviated some of the short-term woes with contract restructures, they'll continue to face difficult decisions on key veterans in future offseasons.
Roethlisberger, if retained long term, is less likely to regress sooner than Brady and Manning because he's only 32. But while we don't know just how good the talent around Brady and Manning would perform with a replacement quarterback, we can assert that the Steelers' supporting cast doesn't stack up to either of the other two teams being discussed. Our panel of FPR voters came to an overall rating of 73.75 for the rest of the Steelers' roster outside of the quarterback, 15th overall in the NFL. That might even be too generous.
The offense is one deep in proven receivers (
Antonio Brown), the offensive line remains a work in progress and the defense was practically devoid of playmakers in 2013 (44 combined interceptions and sacks was fourth fewest in the NFL). The Steelers look faster on defense after this most recent draft, but will that be enough to turn around their alarmingly poor inability to force turnovers?
Lastly, consider the division. While the AFC East includes two of the three lowest-ranked teams in FPR (Buffalo and Miami), and the AFC West includes our overall bottom dweller (Oakland), the Steelers are one of three AFC North teams to check in among our top 13 (Baltimore and Cincinnati included). It'll be tough sledding for every team in that division in the near future.
What could keep them in it: Historical context doesn't always carry weight, but the Steelers are the model NFL franchise in terms of consistent winning. They've endured just five losing seasons since 1972, with the most recent coming in 2003.
While our FPR did not include a separate ranking for ownership, the Rooney family has laid the foundation for the Steelers' success. While the NFL is growing into an increasingly knee-jerk reaction league as it pertains to coach and front office turnover, the Rooneys have long understood the value of stability at the top. Current head coach Mike Tomlin is one of just three men to patrol the Pittsburgh sideline since 1969. The Browns have had three head coaches since December 31, 2012.
But, as previously mentioned, the leg up on sustained success that the Steelers have over the Patriots and Broncos is Roethlisberger being 32. President Art Rooney II made no bones about the team's desire earlier this offseason, declaring: "We've got to have Ben retire as a Steeler. There's no doubt about that." It won't come cheap, but a long-term extension for Roethlisberger keeps the Steelers solidified under center. No position matters more to success in the NFL.