D GRADES
Dallas Cowboys
Grade: D
Key signings: DT Henry Melton, DE Jeremy Mincey, QB Brandon Weeden
Key subtractions: DE DeMarcus Ware, WR Miles Austin, DT Jason Hatcher
Getting Melton on a one-year deal carrying little risk to the team provided at least some light during a dark offseason for the cap-strapped Cowboys. However, there are some rumblings that Melton could be a bit behind schedule in his rehab. Overall, the Cowboys lost more than they gained. Releasing Ware would have made more sense in retrospect if the team could have re-signed him to a more reasonable deal. Instead, the Cowboys watched their most accomplish pass-rusher bolt for Denver while Hatcher, their leading sacker in 2013, signed with Washington.
We could applaud the Cowboys for showing welcome restraint in player valuation, but the reality is that Dallas was hamstrung.
"I lump Carolina and Dallas into a similar category because they're so strapped under the cap that there is little they could do, but the critical difference is that the current Carolina regime is picking up the pieces from Marty Hurney, while the Cowboys are dealing with self-inflicted cap woes," Yates said.
The Cowboys have continually bought flexibility in the short term by pushing cap charges into the future. It caught up to them during this free-agent signing period when the team ran out of contracts to revisit.
"It's amazing how many bad deals they have done over the years," Riddikk said.
Buffalo Bills
Grade: D
Key signings: G Chris Williams, LB Brandon Spikes, CB Corey Graham, LB Keith Rivers, TE Scott Chandler
Key subtractions: FS Jairus Byrd, QB Kevin Kolb
The Bills lost their best young player (Byrd) and paid a relative premium for players such as Williams, who has not been a consistent performer. They also continue to operate without a viable veteran quarterback behind EJ Manuel while other teams scrambled to sign the few available candidates.
"The quarterback situation is very much a question mark for me," Riddikk said. "The No. 2 quarterback is a top-30 position on a 53-man roster. Last year, they start the year with Manuel and an undrafted rookie. I do not know how you do that. Kolb never worked out. Tarvaris Jackson is out of there. They went from him to Kevin to Jeff Tuel to Thad Lewis. Getting the profile right for the No. 2 quarterback is key -- Chicago last year is the best example -- and Buffalo hasn't done it."
The Bills could be in a situation where they need to overpay for a shot at landing even middle-tier free agents. Is that any excuse?
"I think the Bills will get hammered a bit for perceived overpays on Graham and Williams, but both players fill holes," Yates said. "The Bills need four cornerbacks in the AFC East. Graham, Stephon Gilmore, Nickell Robey and Leodis McKelvin give them a nice start. Rivers can still play in space, too, so I liked that signing."
Dallas Cowboys
Grade: D
Key signings: DT Henry Melton, DE Jeremy Mincey, QB Brandon Weeden
Key subtractions: DE DeMarcus Ware, WR Miles Austin, DT Jason Hatcher
Getting Melton on a one-year deal carrying little risk to the team provided at least some light during a dark offseason for the cap-strapped Cowboys. However, there are some rumblings that Melton could be a bit behind schedule in his rehab. Overall, the Cowboys lost more than they gained. Releasing Ware would have made more sense in retrospect if the team could have re-signed him to a more reasonable deal. Instead, the Cowboys watched their most accomplish pass-rusher bolt for Denver while Hatcher, their leading sacker in 2013, signed with Washington.
We could applaud the Cowboys for showing welcome restraint in player valuation, but the reality is that Dallas was hamstrung.
"I lump Carolina and Dallas into a similar category because they're so strapped under the cap that there is little they could do, but the critical difference is that the current Carolina regime is picking up the pieces from Marty Hurney, while the Cowboys are dealing with self-inflicted cap woes," Yates said.
The Cowboys have continually bought flexibility in the short term by pushing cap charges into the future. It caught up to them during this free-agent signing period when the team ran out of contracts to revisit.
"It's amazing how many bad deals they have done over the years," Riddikk said.
Buffalo Bills
Grade: D
Key signings: G Chris Williams, LB Brandon Spikes, CB Corey Graham, LB Keith Rivers, TE Scott Chandler
Key subtractions: FS Jairus Byrd, QB Kevin Kolb
The Bills lost their best young player (Byrd) and paid a relative premium for players such as Williams, who has not been a consistent performer. They also continue to operate without a viable veteran quarterback behind EJ Manuel while other teams scrambled to sign the few available candidates.
"The quarterback situation is very much a question mark for me," Riddikk said. "The No. 2 quarterback is a top-30 position on a 53-man roster. Last year, they start the year with Manuel and an undrafted rookie. I do not know how you do that. Kolb never worked out. Tarvaris Jackson is out of there. They went from him to Kevin to Jeff Tuel to Thad Lewis. Getting the profile right for the No. 2 quarterback is key -- Chicago last year is the best example -- and Buffalo hasn't done it."
The Bills could be in a situation where they need to overpay for a shot at landing even middle-tier free agents. Is that any excuse?
"I think the Bills will get hammered a bit for perceived overpays on Graham and Williams, but both players fill holes," Yates said. "The Bills need four cornerbacks in the AFC East. Graham, Stephon Gilmore, Nickell Robey and Leodis McKelvin give them a nice start. Rivers can still play in space, too, so I liked that signing."