McShay's top QB prospects for 2017
College football is almost upon us, which means the 2017 NFL draft will be here before you know it. Those of us at Scouts Inc. -- Kevin Weidl, Steve Muench and I -- spent the summer scouring tape and ranking the top players at each position from a draft perspective.
Below is our preseason evaluation of the best quarterbacks in the 2017 draft.
Note: Underclassmen are marked with an asterisk.
1. Deshaun Watson, Clemson*
Grade: 88
A dynamic playmaker, Watson has the ability to both throw from the pocket and extend plays with his mobility. He played his best football down the stretch of 2015, throwing for 405 yards and four touchdowns in Clemson's 45-40 loss to Alabama in the College Football Playoff National Championship. Watson (6-foot-2, 210) lacks ideal size and will need to adjust to a pro-style system, but he has the tools to develop into a good starter in the NFL if developed and utilized properly.
2. Brad Kaaya, Miami*
Grade: 87
Kaaya is listed at 6-foot-4, 215 pounds, so he'll need to add some bulk and strength to his frame. But he can really excel in a precision/timing-based offense. Decisive with his full-field reads, Kaaya showed very good accuracy on short-to-intermediate throws and consistently made good pre-snap decisions.
3. C.J. Beathard, Iowa
Grade: 75
Beathard showed great toughness and leadership last season, as he played through injury and led the Hawkeyes to a Rose Bowl berth. He can drive the ball vertically with his quick, compact delivery and has the quickness to slide in the pocket to elude pressure. If Beathard continues to improve his footwork, he could be an early-round pick in 2017.
4. Luke Falk, Washington State*
Grade: 74
Playing in Mike Leach's passer-friendly spread offense, Falk will have to adjust to the NFL game whenever he turns pro. But he has an intriguing skill set, with the ability to go through full-field progressions. A good fit for a timing-based offense, Falk has very good anticipatory accuracy. He consistently leads receivers to spots between defenders in zone coverage.
5. Chad Kelly, Mississippi
Grade: 70
A highly competitive player, Kelly can create his own play at times, but he also gets himself into trouble by trying to do too much. Ole Miss' spread offense runs a lot of quick screens and features a lot of half-field reads, so Kelly still needs to prove that he can work through progressions. He's naturally accurate on short-to-intermediate throws, but he must become a better overall decision-maker and reign in his gun-slinger mentality.
6. Mitch Leidner, Minnesota
Grade: 62
Leidner does not have a big arm, but he can improve his ball velocity by getting his lower body more involved in his throws. He plays in a zone-read-heavy run offense and is a competitive runner with above-average vision, speed and toughness. Leidner hung tough in the pocket behind an offensive line that struggled to protect. He has elite intangibles.
7. Baker Mayfield, Oklahoma*
Grade: 60
A former walk-on and Texas Tech transfer, Mayfield exceeded expectations in his first season as the Sooners' starter. He has the football intelligence, accuracy and mobility to develop into one of the better backups in the NFL, but his frame could prevent him from becoming a full-time starter. Although Mayfield shows above-average decision-making as a passer, he takes a lot of punishment trying to extend plays.
8. Mason Rudolph, Oklahoma*
Grade: 59
A true junior, Rudolph has started just 15 career games, so his grade could change drastically. He has the frame and mental make-up that you look for, but his below average arm strength is concerning. The ball hangs in the air too long, and he throws a lot of floaters. A promising sign: Rudolph has led six second-half, come-from-behind victories in his career.
9. Gunner Kiel, Cincinnati
Grade: 56
Kiel has an ideal frame and good arm strength, and he can pound the strike zone on short-to-intermediate throws when on a roll, but his accuracy is pretty streaky. His biggest issue? Questionable decision-making. He takes too many chances and repeats mistakes. Kiel will need to make substantial strides in this area to improve his stock.
10. Seth Russell, Baylor
Grade: 50
Russell is coming off season-ending neck injury, and he has just eight career starts, but his frame and athletic ability give him some upside. His short-to-intermediate accuracy is erratic, which is an issue considering he plays in Baylor's passer-friendly scheme. Russell faces a steep learning curve transitioning to an NFL-style offense, but his nearly elite arm strength helps make him an intriguing prospect.