Essential The Official Comic Book Discussion Thread [Support @Neuromancer’s book!]

Primetime

Superstar
Joined
May 7, 2012
Messages
12,044
Reputation
2,544
Daps
39,643
Reppin
H-Town
Speaking of continuity, I was scrollin through the CBR Spidey subforum and a poster had a great quote/perspective:

The single timeline was the innovation that reinvigorated superhero comics.

The sliding timeline was the innovation to stretch out its viability.

I sincerely doubt that was supposed to be the end of it, just the patch job that would work until someone came up with something better to maintain longevity.

Another chimed in:

I'm starting to appreciate Marvel as something different from one big ongoing story, better appreciated in discrete units (IE- Hickman's Avengers, Slott's Spider-Man) than pretending that a Lee/ Kirby comic published in 1964 is set a decade earlier than a comic book published and set in 2024.

The sliding timescale starts to collapse at a point. Anachronisms pop up. References hint at different things. The adventures of characters add up in weird ways.

I dunno what the solution is, but another element is that the top brass (Disney, WB, Sony) only care about mining superhero IPs to feed into their actual money makers (films, games, theme parks, etc), which begets starter-kit versions of the characters that are "modernized" for current times (and not the 1960s packages)... which has a varying trickle down effect with the comics.
 
Last edited:

Mr. Negative

Can't change overnight like Ebenezer
Supporter
Joined
Aug 10, 2012
Messages
28,600
Reputation
7,986
Daps
80,489
Reppin
A Mississippi Cotton Field
Speaking of continuity, I was scrollin through the CBR Spidey subforum and a poster had a great quote/perspective:



Another chimed in:



I dunno what the solution is, but another element is that the top brass (Disney, WB, Sony) only care about mining superhero IPs to feed into their actual money makers (films, games, theme parks, etc), which begets starter-kit versions of the characters that are "modernized" for current times (and not the 1960s packages)... which has a varying trickle down effect with the comics.

the only real solution is to only use future dates, past locations and only use "x years ago"/months when referencing present time.

Like if a story (or part of it) is set in Dallas, 1963, then thats fine. "Dallas, 1963". You can use all the dated references and landmarks you want.

If you wanna say Spider-Man first appeared as a teen and he's an adult now, just say "13 years ago.....". No need to reference Drake winning a grammy or the Control verse. If you show a TV, just have it showing local news relevant to the story being told.

Now is just "Now". Give or take a few years.

The Future, as far as dates go, can be anything and it can look any kinda way. Both Marvel and DC have shyt tons of time travellers as this point. Any future that doesnt come to pass by a certain date can easily be waved away as Kang or Flash or Rip Hunter or Per Degaton forgot to flush a toilet and history changed.


Characters that are tied to specific events (Magneto, for instance), just kill and resurrect as needed. Cap still goes on ice during World War 2, you don't have to say he was found in the 60s. All those stories still happened. What date did the President off himself in front of Cap after being revealed to be the leader of the Secret Empire? Who knows? Coulda been any time after 1980. JSA fought in WW2? They were stuck in Ragnarok. Stuff like that is easily explained away.


That's my take on it. No need for a sliding timeline if you don't pin it down with dates.
 

Mr. Negative

Can't change overnight like Ebenezer
Supporter
Joined
Aug 10, 2012
Messages
28,600
Reputation
7,986
Daps
80,489
Reppin
A Mississippi Cotton Field
*reads x-factor*

what the hell is this :heh:

I don't even know if I was entertained or not. It's like they took Giffen's (outstanding and underrated) Suicide Squad and his Justice League International and threw them in a blender.
 

Primetime

Superstar
Joined
May 7, 2012
Messages
12,044
Reputation
2,544
Daps
39,643
Reppin
H-Town
the only real solution is to only use future dates, past locations and only use "x years ago"/months when referencing present time.

Like if a story (or part of it) is set in Dallas, 1963, then thats fine. "Dallas, 1963". You can use all the dated references and landmarks you want.

If you wanna say Spider-Man first appeared as a teen and he's an adult now, just say "13 years ago.....". No need to reference Drake winning a grammy or the Control verse. If you show a TV, just have it showing local news relevant to the story being told.

Now is just "Now". Give or take a few years.

The Future, as far as dates go, can be anything and it can look any kinda way. Both Marvel and DC have shyt tons of time travellers as this point. Any future that doesnt come to pass by a certain date can easily be waved away as Kang or Flash or Rip Hunter or Per Degaton forgot to flush a toilet and history changed.


Characters that are tied to specific events (Magneto, for instance), just kill and resurrect as needed. Cap still goes on ice during World War 2, you don't have to say he was found in the 60s. All those stories still happened. What date did the President off himself in front of Cap after being revealed to be the leader of the Secret Empire? Who knows? Coulda been any time after 1980. JSA fought in WW2? They were stuck in Ragnarok. Stuff like that is easily explained away.


That's my take on it. No need for a sliding timeline if you don't pin it down with dates.

Along those lines I’m thinking there just needs to be a definitive “dateless” timeline starting in the present (“Now”) and working backwards… with 5-8 essential milestone markers for the overall universe and 5-8 internal markers for each major IP, to serve as governance for all creatives and editorial.

Anything outside of these essential milestone markers don’t need to be referenced by the next creative team. And perhaps every decade, marvel editorial committee decides if timeline(s) should be adjusted or a new milestone event added. Have a generic timeline page at the start of every comic.

i.e. maybe Miller’s Civil War becomes a mandated milestone event dated 5 years ago but Bendis’ Civil War 2 isn’t, and so Bruce and Tony “dying” never has to be acknowledged.
 
Top