King Harlem
Superstar
I am all for a Suicide Squad type book in the X-Universe but everything about this book requires the reader to suspend disbelief and buy that so many usually intelligent characters are now dumb as fukk.
Putting Mr. Sinister in charge of a group of mentally damaged, anti-social mutant malcontents makes zero sense.
Tossing Havok into the group as if working for Mr. Sinister on kill missions will somehow help him get over his emotional issues makes even less sense. If they want Havok to get well then plant a Krakoa seed in Doc Samson's office and have Havok lay on Samson's couch twice a week.
And Psylocke just went through her own major life change by splitting out the Betsy Braddock and Kwannon so that the Psylocke in this book really doesn't have the history they are writing her to have with most of these characters. Her being made the leader makes zero sense because the Psylocke who has been in leadership positions with the different XS-teams was Betsy Braddock.
The whole thing is a bit of a cluster fukk if you scratch the surface of the book's concept even a little bit.
To be fair most of the Quiet Council are villains or at the very least have questionable morality: Apocalypse, Magneto, Mister Sinister, Exodus, Mystique, Emma Frost, and Sebastian Shaw (lightweight Professor X, but I won't include him in this). That's 7 out of 11 people (Kitty is never there).