Immaculate came out on Prime yesterday. It's the best horror movie I've watched this year (but bear in mind that I'm waiting until Friday to watch
Late Night with the Devil and still haven't seen
The First Omen).
Cecilia, a woman of devout faith, is warmly welcomed to the picture-perfect Italian countryside where she is offered a new role at an illustrious convent. But it becomes clear to Cecilia that her new home harbors dark and horrifying secrets.
The good:
It's a tried-and-true premise: an innocent woman in a new place, surrounded by nice-seeming people with ominous vibes. I think it goes a little too subtle with the creepy early on, not establishing physical threats fast enough beyond the opening teaser. But all the talk about being inspired by
Rosemary's Baby makes sense. It worked for me because I'd been forewarned that a slow start would let them build up to something crazy.
Anyway, the first half of this movie is subtle, but then it starts to hit with some nasty moments. When the film decides to give you an "oh shyt" moment, the violence and effects are aggressive. It's all about making you squirm in your seat. The nasty moments get you to a final act that is absolute chaos. I didn't love the big reveal because part of it was obvious, and the twist on it wasn't well-seeded. But it worked well enough to make the insanity work.
Sydney Sweeney BODIES the performance, but credit to her costars as well. The creepy religious figures all nail their parts. The end is a good mix of instant violence and run/hide dynamics. The ending is worth the journey...pure chaos!
The bad:
It's still a slow start that tries to cheat through the early portion with some cheaper jump scares. The jumps are especially annoying because some moments fall in the "psychological horror" realm but get cut short by a jump scare...too many tension releases for a slow-building story. I bet that stuff made the theater experience fun, but it doesn't have the staying power that a single nightmare sequence had.
It's also strange how reality-grounded the story is in such a spiritual setting. For a movie about faith, it cuts out ANY ambiguity. I think that can be a strength for some viewers. But I'd have liked it if things were implied rather than blatantly explained.
Final Score:
In a year where everything I've watched has barely been a 7/10. Immaculate is a comfortable 8/10 for me...maybe even 8.5 when I revisit it. But I could be gassing it because there's been such a drought of great horror. Maybe once I watch
Late Night with the Devil and
The First Omen, it'll lose that "refreshing" feeling.