The Hatton example wasn't for you, it's just in general. Paulie only won 4 rounds to me against Broner and they were the early rounds. After the 4th or 5th round he got walked down and rocked every round. That fight was competitive, but it wasn't close. Cotto vs Floyd was more competitive than that, and yet Cotto only won around the same amount of rounds which was 4 at best. I don't agree with winning rounds off of activity when those punches don't land. Paulie was hitting air, elbows, and shoulders all night. If he was catching Broner I could understand awarding him for activity, but he wasn't.
I think Broner beats Matthysee, but Garcia is a 50/50 toss up imo. I would prolly favor Thurman over Broner if they were to fight next year depending on how they look in their next matches.