NO. because the same things you do to go from an F or D student to a C student isn't gonna make you an A or even B student.I mean you're purposely trying to limit what the answer could be by saying top 20. Most of the top 20 have home grown talent with decades of a fine tuned machine supporting and cultivating talent. We're still building that out and everyone acknowledges we're not close to matching their infrastructures yet. The premise of my argument was that our talent pool could increase if we incorporated the same strategies other countries use.
If a country improves its ranking from 150 to 100 due to bringing on non citizens to their roster. Do you believe the USA incorporating the same strategy wouldn't yield some type of uptick in our rankings as well?
Obviously you don't believe that and think we should copy the strategies of the best teams in the world. Which is fine bc thats your opinion
There however are other strategies out there that have shown to have positive results for lower ranked teams. The USA has obviously taken a hard position in not incorporating those strategies by making their rules stricter than Fifa's.
Evaluating all potential strategies to win isn't dumb or stupid, its looking over all of your options. We're not winning anything or even close to doing so.
It's commendable that we want to make sure our citizens are on our team.Doesn't mean its the 100% right thing to do for the USA to beat the best
I mean you're purposely trying to limit what the answer could be by saying top 20. Most of the top 20 have home grown talent with decades of a fine tuned machine supporting and cultivating talent. We're still building that out and everyone acknowledges we're not close to matching their infrastructures yet. The premise of my argument was that our talent pool could increase if we incorporated the same strategies other countries use.
If a country improves its ranking from 150 to 100 due to bringing on non citizens to their roster. Do you believe the USA incorporating the same strategy wouldn't yield some type of uptick in our rankings as well?
Obviously you don't believe that and think we should copy the strategies of the best teams in the world. Which is fine bc thats your opinion
There however are other strategies out there that have shown to have positive results for lower ranked teams. The USA has obviously taken a hard position in not incorporating those strategies by making their rules stricter than Fifa's.
Evaluating all potential strategies to win isn't dumb or stupid, its looking over all of your options. We're not winning anything or even close to doing so.
It's commendable that we want to make sure our citizens are on our team.
Like the spread offense in american CFB, started out in the lower tiers of D1, people shyt on it for a decade; but once the top teams gave it a try with better athletes and execution its fukking everywhere now. No one would say the top CFB teams adopting the spread offense going from being a B team to A team was stupid bc the only people with the track record were small F teams going to D teams.
In athletics for the Olympics, yes.
As for their team that just won the Asian Cup, who are the mercenaries? Damn near the whole team was raised through their academy systems that they built up at the start of the century. Try again.
you dk what ur talking about themWrong. The ones who mattered didn’t until they were mid teens. Qatar implemented the exact model I was stating. Get em in early, get that 5 years and boom they’re now eligible. If you dk that udk football and there’s no reason to keep talking to u.
Other countries wanted to file complaints against them
they had ten guys. I believe 1 or 2 came in to Qatar before 15.
You said "top talent". Who are the dudes you are talking about and what other countries were they eligible for?
They did not have 10.
You still did not name any of these top talents.
If it was that easy, Qatar, of all teams, would have a Brazilian on their squad. They don't.
Teams lodge complaints over other teams putting out ineligible players all the time. That's not something unique that started with Qatar or in Asian football.
And where did I say Qatar is cherry picking talent for football? You said that. I asked you to name these dudes and you have not been able to do that yet.
