I give it a 6/10. The world felt underdeveloped and the rules for the game world wasn't established well. Like at all. I hate lazy sci-fi and casual/fake nerd culture shyt.
Felt like half the movie was Spielberg going "DO YOU REMEMBER CHUN LI? REMEMBER IRON GIANT? REMEMBER GUNDAM?" Like I dig the cameos just because of who I am, but the whole story just felt flimsy. Lack of police virtually the whole movie in that world. Just a lack of so much. Not to mention the relationship building just felt cheap and too fast. I feel like I'm being generous with the score, but I did really enjoy the visuals. Especially enjoyed getting to the first key visually. But I dunno. Guess I need to lower my expectations for blockbusters again.
Will say that the one F bomb allowed in this one was probably the best I remember since First Class. shyt was unexpected and that whole bit from that scene was great. The best parts of this movie are mostly due to nostalgia and seeing those characters like this.
Edit: Maybe I'm being a bit hard. Upon reflection I'm going to give it a 7/10. The side characters were for the most part really charming. The main character's overall arc was just too cheesy, samesy, and predictable. Just the ultimate good guy type shyt. But movie was still decent.
Edit 2: 6.5/10. I cannot in good faith give this a 7. Too much dumb shyt. Spielberg needs to tighten this shyt up. It ain't the 80s anymore
Maybe the book does a better job explaining it, but I don't think the movie did a good job explaining to me WHY control of the Oasis was so important. From what I gather, the Oasis is not "The Internet", its a *game* that runs on the internet that basically ate all other online games. So...what is stopping someone from just making another game? Why is that worth blowing up a building and killing dozens of people?
If I were the main character, I would have IMMEDIATELY hit the "OFF" button as soon as they showed it to me. Then just walk away with my $500,000,000 and do whatever I want in the real world.
I have to admit, the "Memberberries" really got me at some points though. When the Iron Giant was fighting MechaGozzilla, the rational part of my brain turned off and all I could think was "USE YOUR DAMN CHEST CANNON!!". And as you mentioned I really loved the
scene because I was totally unspoiled about it and it caught me totally by surprise.
Also, I felt really superior for a couple of seconds when I realized that the magic spell to turn off the Orb thing was the "Charm of Making" spell from the movie Excalibur, and I thought I might be the ONLY one in the Imax theater to get the reference. Which was
A. probably not true
and
B. a pretty pointless reference.
I DID like the "Black Mirror"-style hints that maybe the creator of the Oasis uploaded his mind into the system, though.