Star Wars: The Rise of Skywalker (Official Thread)

TobiOT

Veteran
Joined
Jan 29, 2017
Messages
31,158
Reputation
3,313
Daps
77,756
Reppin
East London
I forgot to bring it up

But the opening trailers were literally 30 god damn mins

:dead:

I was 15 mins late and STILL had comfortable time to get some snacks
Lost my headphones in the cinema earlier cause I watched Knives Out first.....still had time to get some stiff and retrieve them to make it on time yesterday.:russ:
 

TobiOT

Veteran
Joined
Jan 29, 2017
Messages
31,158
Reputation
3,313
Daps
77,756
Reppin
East London
MV5BMjQyODQwNTA0Nl5BMl5BanBnXkFtZTgwODA3NjU5NDM@._V1_SX1500_CR0,0,1500,999_AL_.jpg


Ehh....Rose can get the lightsaber
:patrice:
 

NinoBrown

Veteran
Joined
May 6, 2015
Messages
16,908
Reputation
4,946
Daps
78,376
A coward?

Yes? Attempting to murder his innocent nephew in his sleep? Essentially laying low during the First Order's reign of terror instead of joining the fight like he did in the OT?

OT Luke was ready to die for the Rebellion....Hermit Crab Luke was willing to let the galaxy burn because he was afraid...
 

HHR

Do what you love
Joined
Apr 30, 2012
Messages
19,021
Reputation
1,622
Daps
39,392
Yes? Attempting to murder his innocent nephew in his sleep? Essentially laying low during the First Order's reign of terror instead of joining the fight like he did in the OT?

OT Luke was ready to die for the Rebellion....Hermit Crab Luke was willing to let the galaxy burn because he was afraid...

I think it's more nuanced than cowardice. Disillusionment, bitterness, frustration, etc. Most people change over 30 years. Expecting him to be the same and then being angry when he's not is pretty dumb, imo.

But the bolded is fundamentally wrong, isn't it? He briefly considered murdering him, but never actually attempted it. And was he really innocent? There's an interesting ethical discussion to be had there about preemptive action towards evil. The Roshomon-esque retelling of that moment is one of my favorite parts of TLJ.
 

goatmane

Veteran
Joined
Jan 26, 2017
Messages
16,711
Reputation
2,504
Daps
114,105
I mean JJ put Rian in a difficult position to have to explain why Luke left and didn’t tell anyone where he was


The first film that made $2 billion, highest grossing movie in US history, first in a planned trilogy, left its next sequel with nothing? In fact, JJ already had ep 8 planed out and met Rian like 10 times so...

You guys just lyin now...?

You notice the difference in hype between TLJ and RoS? Becsuse |ian left fans with nothing to hype themselves for in Episode 9. Absolutely nothing.

He had complete creative control. Disney trusted him so much, they didnt do their usual stepping in during production. Stop it

Next u gonna blame JJ for Rion killing Snoke right
 
Last edited:

Eddy Gordo

Banned
Supporter
Joined
Nov 18, 2016
Messages
4,148
Reputation
615
Daps
13,933
I think it's more nuanced than cowardice. Disillusionment, bitterness, frustration, etc. Most people change over 30 years. Expecting him to be the same and then being angry when he's not is pretty dumb, imo.

But the bolded is fundamentally wrong, isn't it? He briefly considered murdering him, but never actually attempted it. And was he really innocent? There's an interesting ethical discussion to be had there about preemptive action towards evil. The Roshomon-esque retelling of that moment is one of my favorite parts of TLJ.
Yes, we expected him to be the same. Because no one gave any sort of clue to this Disillusionment, bitterness, frustration, as you put it. You present the most optimistic of youths and then turn him into a bitter old man. Of course people wanna know how you got from A to B. Your just giving cop outs to weak writing. If you have Gerald Butler as Spiderman in the next marvel movie being the villan committing genocide people are going to have questions.

And no it's not fundamentally wrong. Just because you back out of the attempt doesn't mean that attempt wasn't made. Yes he was innocent. This isn't minority report.

You like a bad movie. It's ok.
 
Last edited:

NinoBrown

Veteran
Joined
May 6, 2015
Messages
16,908
Reputation
4,946
Daps
78,376
I think it's more nuanced than cowardice. Disillusionment, bitterness, frustration, etc. Most people change over 30 years. Expecting him to be the same and then being angry when he's not is pretty dumb, imo.

But the bolded is fundamentally wrong, isn't it? He briefly considered murdering him, but never actually attempted it. And was he really innocent? There's an interesting ethical discussion to be had there about preemptive action towards evil. The Roshomon-esque retelling of that moment is one of my favorite parts of TLJ.

The central characters in this saga remained the same more or less, Han and Leia aged 30 years and haven't changed from what we've seen.


Going further back, Obi-Wan lost all faith and hope, all his friends and allies pretty much killed by his apprentice in the same day, and forced into exile for decades.

However when he got his chance to strike at the Empire, he took a chance without question or hesitation.

I find it unbelievable a student who sought the redemption of Vader would be driven to try to kill his nephew, regardless of the passage of time.

Luke placed blood/family/friendship over ancient feuds and ideology.
 

ExodusNirvana

Change is inevitable...
Joined
Jun 6, 2012
Messages
41,064
Reputation
9,165
Daps
150,344
Reppin
Brooklyn, NY
All wouldbe been forgiven if he did that imo. I truly wanted to see Rey join the darkside with Ren. Have Luke survive and have to deal with the mess his inactivity caused
And then train Finn to save her...or even save them both with Ben still ultimately sacrificing himself for the greater good, just like his grandfather did

You could show Rey struggling to give in to the Dark Side and show how a Sith trains its pupil :yeshrug:
 

Jmare007

pico pal q lee
Joined
Apr 30, 2012
Messages
44,814
Reputation
5,974
Daps
109,545
Reppin
Chile
Annoying azz Rose fans smh






I honestly don't get it. Did she get paid way less than in TLJ? The only thing that Last Jedi got any consensus on was Canto Bight being horrible and most people thought the Finn/Rose relationship was either weird, rushed or complete bullshyt :heh:

The same people fake outraging over Kelly Marie Tran getting the :camby: in ROS would be crying foul over people shytting on her character if she actually got a lot of screen time in this last movie :mjlol:

If anyone got done diry in this sequel trilogy it was Gwendoline Christie and no one gave a shyt about it :pachaha:
 
Top