Spin: When did you finally realize that Jay Z's discography is borderline trash?

[wingstop]

Yeah you right.

RD: HIT
Vol 1: MISS
Vol2: HIT
Vol3:HIT
Dynasty: HIT (for me)(Puttin on the ROC, was a group album almost)
Bluprint 1: HIT
Bluprint 2: Miss (Commercial HIT)
BestBothWorlds: HIT (thanks to kel)
Black Album: RETIREMENT ALBUM (MISS)
---------------------------------------------------
KC: MISS
AG:HIT
BP3: MISS
MCHG: MISS
WTT: MISS

Black album, vol 1 and WTT are misses?

 

[Billy Ocean]

idk know how anyone can think stillmatic is a better album than american gangster

HW assignment: Listen to Stillmatic in full then listen to AG in full right after it. Dont skip any tracks and after you listened to both come back to me

You'll see who's right

You trying way too hard right now, Tochi. Nobody co-signing you

 

[Niqqa You Gay]

vol 3 >>>>>>>>> nastradamus

Doesn't mean it was a good album. Nastradamus is an all time dud, so there are a whole lot of albums better than that

 

[King P]

idk know how anyone can think stillmatic is a better album than american gangster

HW assignment: Listen to Stillmatic in full then listen to AG in full right after it. Dont skip any tracks and after you listened to both come back to me

You'll see who's right

Stillmatic's best songs >>> AG's

Stop it breh

 

[T.H.E. Goat]

vol 3 >>>>>>>>> nastradamus

I throughly remember enjoying Nastradumas more than Vol. 3

Now I'll be fair because I haven't revisited that album in a while, but at the time Vol. 3 was one song away from being a trash album in my opinion

 

[wingstop]

You trying way too hard right now, Tochi. Nobody co-signing you

go listen to both projects back to back. AG is better in almost every way, its simply just a better put together project

 

[Billy Ocean]

go listen to both projects back to back. AG is better in almost every way, its simply just a better put together project

Ok, Tochi.

 

[wingstop]

Stillmatic's best songs >>> AG's

Stop it breh

yes 2nd childhood, the intro and youre da man are better than almost every song on AG

but there is also some trash and a lot of songs with weak production

you don't judge projects by only 2 or 3 tracks, you judge it based on the whole album and in no way is stillmatic better than AG.

 

[revan]

Jay has some duds but BP2 isn't one of them. It reminds me of another forced double LP in Streets Disciple in that if I cut the fat there's still enough really good songs to make it a quality body of work.

 

[Zero]

4 pages yet the first 3 got the same 4-5 people posting back to back

 

[IllmaticDelta]

American gangster and the black album are both better albums than stillmatic.

 

[Billy Ocean]

4 pages yet the first 3 got the same 4-5 people posting back to back

Must be because most people agree. Nothing really needs to be said. You agree or nah?

 

[onelastdeath]

When did American Gangster become this classic all of a sudden?


It had some dope songs but I don't remember anyone saying it's a classic(offline)

It is a classic and even if you think it's not it's still a better record than Stillmatic.

 

[Zero]

Must be because most people agree. Nothing really needs to be said. You agree or nah?

 

[wingstop]

they are. How can an album like stillmatic which has some weak production and tracks like smokin, braveheart party, and rule be better than an album like the black album and american gangster?