Spin: When did you finally realize that Jay Z's discography is borderline trash?

T.H.E. Goat

On the road to riches
Supporter
Joined
Jun 26, 2012
Messages
14,514
Reputation
3,689
Daps
51,325
Reppin
Where The Grass Is Blue
How can people shyt on Nastradamus and then turn around and say Vol.3 was a good album
full
 

QuintessentialMan

Banned
Supporter
Joined
Nov 22, 2016
Messages
4,418
Reputation
1,109
Daps
13,882
Eminem has plenty of trash albums, he is the one your looking for OP.
Aside from his first 3 albums. The rest were garbage. Some people dont even let me say first 3, They say only first 2. I think thats harsh.
 

Billy Ocean

Divine Universal Black Man Representin'
Supporter
Joined
May 9, 2012
Messages
42,777
Reputation
9,365
Daps
207,788
Reppin
TPC
nastradamus, streets disciple, HHID, untitled

Nastradamus: I agree...shyt garbage.

Streets Disciple: Not really garbage, just boring. Wouldn't call it trash...just forgettable and waaaaay too long.

HHID: Average/mediocre

Untitled: Damn near classic to a bunch of people. Stellar album, breh. You need to revisit.
 

Billy Ocean

Divine Universal Black Man Representin'
Supporter
Joined
May 9, 2012
Messages
42,777
Reputation
9,365
Daps
207,788
Reppin
TPC
Eminem has plenty of trash albums, he is the one your looking for OP.
Aside from his first 3 albums. The rest were garbage. Some people dont even let me say first 3, They say only first 2. I think thats harsh.

I don't even consider Eminem. Most overrated rapper of all-time. If we were to consider Eminem, then yea, he has waaaaaay more dud albums than Jay. But I'm not even considering him.
 

Billy Ocean

Divine Universal Black Man Representin'
Supporter
Joined
May 9, 2012
Messages
42,777
Reputation
9,365
Daps
207,788
Reppin
TPC
When did American Gangster become this classic all of a sudden?


It had some dope songs but I don't remember anyone saying it's a classic(offline)

American Gangster is not a classic. Just a very dope album. People tend to overrate it because it was made by Jay and they were shocked at how dope it was especially coming after Kingdom Come.
 

King P

Legends Never Die
Joined
Nov 12, 2012
Messages
15,547
Reputation
3,433
Daps
48,707
Reppin
Views From The X
When did American Gangster become this classic all of a sudden?


It had some dope songs but I don't remember anyone saying it's a classic(offline)
It's not a classic, but it damn might as well be when you compare it to that bullshyt Kingdom Come album, or the albums he dropped after AG
 
Last edited:

QuintessentialMan

Banned
Supporter
Joined
Nov 22, 2016
Messages
4,418
Reputation
1,109
Daps
13,882
Not trash, but he really should have stopped after The Black Album. Post TBA, his only dope album was American Gangster.

Yeah you right.

RD: HIT
Vol 1: MISS
Vol2: HIT
Vol3:HIT
Dynasty: HIT (for me)(Puttin on the ROC, was a group album almost)
Bluprint 1: HIT
Bluprint 2: Miss (Commercial HIT)
BestBothWorlds: HIT (thanks to kel)
Black Album: RETIREMENT ALBUM (MISS)
---------------------------------------------------
KC: MISS
AG:HIT
BP3: MISS
MCHG: MISS
WTT: MISS
 

Billy Ocean

Divine Universal Black Man Representin'
Supporter
Joined
May 9, 2012
Messages
42,777
Reputation
9,365
Daps
207,788
Reppin
TPC
Yeah you right.

RD: HIT
Vol 1: MISS
Vol2: HIT
Vol3:HIT
Dynasty: HIT (for me)(Puttin on the ROC, was a group album almost)
Bluprint 1: HIT
Bluprint 2: Miss (Commercial HIT)
BestBothWorlds: HIT (thanks to kel)
Black Album: RETIREMENT ALBUM (MISS)
---------------------------------------------------
KC: MISS
AG:HIT
BP3: MISS
MCHG: MISS
WTT: MISS


That's alot of misses there, breh :mjgrin:
 

King P

Legends Never Die
Joined
Nov 12, 2012
Messages
15,547
Reputation
3,433
Daps
48,707
Reppin
Views From The X
Yeah you right.

RD: HIT
Vol 1: MISS
Vol2: HIT
Vol3:HIT
Dynasty: HIT (for me)(Puttin on the ROC, was a group album almost)
Bluprint 1: HIT
Bluprint 2: Miss (Commercial HIT)
BestBothWorlds: HIT (thanks to kel)
Black Album: RETIREMENT ALBUM (MISS)
---------------------------------------------------
KC: MISS
AG:HIT
BP3: MISS
MCHG: MISS
WTT: MISS
I didn't count WTT because it wasn't a solo, but I actually fukked with it.

I think Vol. 1 is criminally underrated. Take out a couple a songs, and the album is really good. I actually don't mind the Sunshine song, but the video is what makes it cony as hell :russ:
 
Top