Not even stupidity. It's Phil's obsession with maintaining the "Good Guy Phil" forward facing persona.
If they want to make the games exclusive, just say it. But trying to play the public perception game by saying one thing, but then doing the other (shout out to all those Bethesda games you'll probably be able to play wherever you want. ) is really the center of the issue here.
no doubt. people can see through the bullshyt. Dude stays lying. And now it's gonna cost them.