DropTopDoc
20/20 Vision With my Buffs On
Explain to me how qbs across different coaching staffs, with different skill sets, and personnel are like
Shedeur Sanders vs Caleb Williams as NFL prospects
- Thread starter Apprentice
- Start date
Explain to me how qbs across different coaching staffs, with different skill sets, and personnel are like
IIVI
Superstar
Somebody once said Shedeur is actually very situationally aware about the sacks that he takes.
Dude will rather take the sack than throw a bad ball, which also explains the low interception counts.
Again, not saying Shedeur is better, but dude is a very smart player and that formal pedigree is quite apparent. That's a big part of the intrigue because that'll always transfer on the football field at every level.
Dr. Narcisse
Veteran
Depends on where they go.
But as of TODAY
Caleb is Mahomes when the play breaks down, but Houston Deshuan in the pocket and past the line of scrimmage.
Shedeur is Jameis Winston with Teddy Bridgewater's decision making.
Now I personally believe Jameis would have been really good if he had more chill decision making.
I have to see how Shedeur plays against Oregon and USC to project him better. Cause while the Colorado State comeback was impressive. The fact he had to comeback because his feet were incredibly slow in the pocket and outside the pocket. He has to play faster once his 1st read is gone against Oregon and USC.
If he can show better feet and make more tight window throws against those quality opponents then maybe he's more in the Burrow/Seattle Geno mode.
But as of TODAY
Caleb is Mahomes when the play breaks down, but Houston Deshuan in the pocket and past the line of scrimmage.
Shedeur is Jameis Winston with Teddy Bridgewater's decision making.
Now I personally believe Jameis would have been really good if he had more chill decision making.
I have to see how Shedeur plays against Oregon and USC to project him better. Cause while the Colorado State comeback was impressive. The fact he had to comeback because his feet were incredibly slow in the pocket and outside the pocket. He has to play faster once his 1st read is gone against Oregon and USC.
If he can show better feet and make more tight window throws against those quality opponents then maybe he's more in the Burrow/Seattle Geno mode.
We’ll know in 2 weeks.
C Will has Rodgers Mahomes type arm talent
You don’t watch Shaduer play, clearly. He zips that boy through tight pockets as well and throws accurate deep balls. This is without a solid o-line. The boy arm is eite as well.
Asking posters who only watched maybe 4 games of Sanders and rarely watch SC isn't gonna get you good answers.
They are different QB types.
Shedeur is a pocket passer who's even showing tremendous game management qualities
Celeb is a dynamic mobile QB who also has everything needed to be an elite balanced QB prospect.
Everyone wants balanced QBs in the 2020s so the clear lean is Williams. That said elite pocket passers are what has always won in the NFL.
Both are special prospects to me. I see them are clearly the top two QBs in this class.
Who's better, the one that goes to the best scheme, coaching, and personnel in the NFL. No QB can do it by themselves, especially early on.
Both are tier 1 prospects. Clearly ahead of Maye and Penix for me. Ewers is someone to keep an eye on.
They are different QB types.
Shedeur is a pocket passer who's even showing tremendous game management qualities
Celeb is a dynamic mobile QB who also has everything needed to be an elite balanced QB prospect.
Everyone wants balanced QBs in the 2020s so the clear lean is Williams. That said elite pocket passers are what has always won in the NFL.
Both are special prospects to me. I see them are clearly the top two QBs in this class.
Who's better, the one that goes to the best scheme, coaching, and personnel in the NFL. No QB can do it by themselves, especially early on.
Both are tier 1 prospects. Clearly ahead of Maye and Penix for me. Ewers is someone to keep an eye on.
IIVI
Superstar
Another thing to consider is how pliable Mahomes is. Dude doesn't get injured and has actually taken some pretty big hits to make those crazy throws. Mahomes is double-jointed/loose-jointed which protects him from a class of injuries. Not a lot of people can play that style, big arm or not.
Not a guarantee Caleb can take those hits to make those plays longterm at the next level. There's so much more to Mahomes's dominance than the football IQ, decision-making, cannon arm and playmaking. I'm pretty sure there are other intangibles many aren't seeing. Funny traits like Barry Bonds having the best examined eyes an opthamologist has seen go into making some of these top-performing athletes truly special.
It's like when people compared Andrew Luck to "A younger, more mobile Peyton Manning". It really overlooks the intricate details about what Mahomes and Manning were able to do and the reasons why they were able to.
Not a guarantee Caleb can take those hits to make those plays longterm at the next level. There's so much more to Mahomes's dominance than the football IQ, decision-making, cannon arm and playmaking. I'm pretty sure there are other intangibles many aren't seeing. Funny traits like Barry Bonds having the best examined eyes an opthamologist has seen go into making some of these top-performing athletes truly special.
It's like when people compared Andrew Luck to "A younger, more mobile Peyton Manning". It really overlooks the intricate details about what Mahomes and Manning were able to do and the reasons why they were able to.
Last edited:
I'm genuinely impressed with what I've seen so far.
Dude looks like a NFL QB it's not hype.
His decision making and accuracy is elite.
Dipsey Doo
Superstar
A lot of y’all are in the moment dikkriders for real
↓R↑LYB
I trained Sheng Long and Shonuff
My dyslexia must be acting up because I keep reading the bolded as USB C. Got me thinking I'm in an iPhone thread
Born2BKing
Veteran
So Caleb is the best player in the league and Shadeur is a 2nd stringer?
West Coast Avenger
West Coastin & Smokin
Let me know when Shadeur has a Heisman under his belt son.....So Caleb is the best player in the league and Shadeur is a 2nd stringer?