Official The Irishman Thread

jwinfield

Veteran
Joined
Apr 30, 2012
Messages
40,709
Reputation
8,485
Daps
198,437
Reppin
NULL
Jimmy Hoffa wasnt good tho. But whatever. I just got pedo vibes from it. Im entitled to say that as a viewer.
Hoffa was on tv and in the newspapers fighting for workers, she saw him as a good dude.

She knew what her dad did and knew him and Russ were on the same shyt, she didn’t trust his ass.
 

jay211

Superstar
Joined
May 25, 2012
Messages
15,909
Reputation
1,459
Daps
44,371
Reppin
NULL
I routinely have 80-100+ Alerts.

I'm well aware of Irwin Winkler's law suit. He claimed the movie made $275 million total. In 2014. Meaning it took 24 years to do more than what "TMNT" did in it's initial run. So how was it more profitable? :patrice:

Also keep in mind you have no idea if these numbers are even true, as they settled out of court. According to WB the movie never even broke even.

AMC is showing "Parasite" 5 minutes away from me.

Also there's an Alamo Drafthouse in Brooklyn. Again, where exactly do you live? :gucci:



You're talking about genres, I'm talking about quality.

You seriously think Scorsese was happy with "Goodfellas" being blown out of the water by "3 Men And A Little Lady"? :mjtf:

Let alone "Total Recall", which was an "amusement park" film from that era.

Which again is my point. "Goodfellas" was the best film on that list by a wide margin....yet it's nowhere near the most successful.

Fred.

Don't ever trust studio accounting. According to WBs accounting HARRY POTTER still hasn't made them money, which is a lie.
 

Zero

Wig-Twisting Season
Joined
Nov 15, 2013
Messages
76,451
Reputation
27,055
Daps
362,439
You mean 6 words. Nobody is crying about it, they're just wondering why an Oscar winning actress was marketed in the promos as a lead and had to audition to say six words.
Groot only had 3
0b99jPyC_o.png
 

hex

Super Moderator
Staff member
Supporter
Joined
May 2, 2012
Messages
38,043
Reputation
18,548
Daps
192,018
Don't ever trust studio accounting. According to WBs accounting HARRY POTTER still hasn't made them money, which is a lie.

I seriously doubt WB is telling the truth about Harry Potter. It'd be damn near impossible.

However, the original talking point was "Goodfellas" which made $46 million in it's original box office run. Which would be considered a flop. Dude I was arguing with starting bringing up how much it made in the subsequent 25+ years since it's release. Which was the topic of a law suit, settled out of court.

So on the one hand you have a guy claiming it made X amount of dollars with no proof available to the public....on the other hand you have WB saying it didn't turn a profit. The truth is between those two extremes.

Fred.
 

TheGodling

Los Ingobernables de Sala de Cine
Joined
May 21, 2013
Messages
20,078
Reputation
5,615
Daps
70,582
Reppin
Rotterdam
no it wasn't . as I didn't know it, and the poster you quoted read it somewhere else. To me it came off like dude was a pedophile more than he was just crooked. Jimmy Hoffa character was even creepier buying her ice cream and shyt.
Breh, I don't care about your delusions and @MartyMcFly being unable to recollect some dialog from a 3 and a half hour movie. Russ and Frank first talk about it at the bowling alley, and there is this bit of literal narration when they first show Hoffa interacting with Frank's daughter like a nice uncle:

'To Peggy, Jimmy wasn't like Russ, Skinny or even me. For one Jimmy didn't have a nickname like The Razor or The Hunchback or The Weasel or Whispers. And to her, he was helping people. He was helping them make more money, live better lives. He wasn't stomping on someone's hand.'

You are literally told why she saw Hoffa as different than Frank and his mob friends.
 

MartyMcFly

What's up doc, can we rock?
Joined
May 29, 2012
Messages
59,888
Reputation
9,180
Daps
161,011
Reppin
P.G. County
Breh, I don't care about your delusions and @MartyMcFly being unable to recollect some dialog from a 3 and a half hour movie. Russ and Frank first talk about it at the bowling alley, and there is this bit of literal narration when they first show Hoffa interacting with Frank's daughter like a nice uncle:

'To Peggy, Jimmy wasn't like Russ, Skinny or even me. For one Jimmy didn't have a nickname like The Razor or The Hunchback or The Weasel or Whispers. And to her, he was helping people. He was helping them make more money, live better lives. He wasn't stomping on someone's hand.'

You are literally told why she saw Hoffa as different than Frank and his mob friends.
And now that you mention it, I recollect. Good work. Do more of that and less of being a condescending a$$hole. It works for you :ehh: appreciate it
 

TheGodling

Los Ingobernables de Sala de Cine
Joined
May 21, 2013
Messages
20,078
Reputation
5,615
Daps
70,582
Reppin
Rotterdam
And now that you mention it, I recollect. Good work. Do more of that and less of being a condescending a$$hole. It works for you :ehh: appreciate it
Nah, you do better and learn to recognize I speak facts at all times. :ufdup:

At all times! :ufdup:
 

hex

Super Moderator
Staff member
Supporter
Joined
May 2, 2012
Messages
38,043
Reputation
18,548
Daps
192,018
Wolf of Wall Street made $400M worldwide and it was rated R, long as fukk... all of the things that we've discussed. It wasn't a mob movie but it was a type of crime drama.

I know you're going to say his last joint didn't make anything but he obviously made that for himself and it didn't catch on, most directors have movies that didn't catch on.

Wolf of Wall Street was more profitable than Dark Phoenix and all those joints that lost a lot of money... it stands to reason that The Irishman could have had a similar run.

There is literally nothing to suggest this movie would've been a hit.

Acting like "Wolf Of Wall Street", a movie that came out 6 years ago, with higher profile stars.....which itself only opened at #5 when released....is somehow proof this would've done well at the box office, is lunacy.

And :gucci: at "'Wolf Of Wall Street' was more profitable than 'Dark Phoenix'"....the fukk does that have to do with anything?
So because a comic movie nobody wanted flopped....that's proof this movie would've been successful? :mjtf:

What is this based on? This is another "'Goodfellas' was more profitable than 'TMNT'" situation. You just say shyt sometimes, with no basis in reality.

The fact of the matter is "Wolf Of Wall Street" is an anomaly in Scorsese's filmography. It only did $392 mill but it's still his highest grossing movie.

Scorsese is not a hit maker, he never was. Most of his movies either under perform, barely break even, or outright flop.

I mean...."Goodfellas" took 24 years to make $275 million....and you acted like it's some amazing feat. :mindblown:

Fred.
 

SnowflakesByTheOZ

Sorry, that's another B
Joined
Feb 12, 2017
Messages
13,865
Reputation
3,400
Daps
57,082
shyt was weak and extra. Overacted by Pacino. :unimpressed::hubie:
I do agree with the Pacino part. In his initial scenes it somehow felt like he was forcing it but eventually it felt right. The scene where he was flipping out in the office saying he was going to jail when De Niro left the room and he convinced him to come back in. That scene didn't feel authentic to me idk is it me or was he repeating some lines too ? Great movie overall though. I wouldn't put it over Casino or Goodfellas but I'm gonna rewatch again.

Oh yea Sebastian Manisalco killed his role
 
Top